Match 2024 NRL Round 3 - Cronulla-Sutherland Sharks vs Wests Tigers, 7.35pm Saturday 23 March @ Leichhardt Oval

Match threads
Joined
Sep 7, 2005
Messages
18,399
Reaction score
2,057
Location
The Ridge!
Glad i didnt watch this game.
Same here.

But the players should be made to watch it, over and over again.

I was wondering too with all the talk about complacency - did we actually go into the game knowing it would be tough and we would have to turn up and then thought we had it won easily when Tom scored his try. From all reports, the first 10-15 minutes wasn't that bad but after Tom's try we turned to ****.
 

Thresher

Jaws
Joined
Jul 5, 2011
Messages
24,763
Reaction score
3,437
Location
Melbourne
I wouldn't make them watch it over and over unless you want them suffering from PTSD.
 

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
30,106
Reaction score
5,983
Location
IN A BAR
Same here.

But the players should be made to watch it, over and over again.

I was wondering too with all the talk about complacency - did we actually go into the game knowing it would be tough and we would have to turn up and then thought we had it won easily when Tom scored his try. From all reports, the first 10-15 minutes wasn't that bad but after Tom's try we turned to ****.
You'd have hoped after Bulldogs (who I would say have a worse roster) stuck strong a big chunk of that game we wouldn't have expected a similar effort from the Tigers.

Maybe that was it too much though. Played like we were waiting for them to collapse and didn't dig in ourselves to force it.
 

BurgoShark

Super Moderator
Joined
Apr 8, 2008
Messages
12,868
Reaction score
4,096
Avoiding the conversation about nobody here being in the sheds and this not actually knowing anything about the players' attitude… why do ALL players have to get accused not putting in? Just because a few guys have an off night it doesn't mean that the rest of the group didn't have their heads in the game.

There were a lot of very good performances across the team. The halves just **** the bed and the 3 injured middles didn't help things.

Tigers also played very well. 2 tries from kicks, 2 from broken play and 1 from a crash ball. They kept it simple and took their chances.
 

apezza

Great White
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
4,247
Reaction score
1,989
Same here.

But the players should be made to watch it, over and over again.

I was wondering too with all the talk about complacency - did we actually go into the game knowing it would be tough and we would have to turn up and then thought we had it won easily when Tom scored his try. From all reports, the first 10-15 minutes wasn't that bad but after Tom's try we turned to ****.

I thought we started ok - similar to first two weeks. Set for set then we scored.

We then just seemed to stop doing the 1 percenters where Tigers excelled at.

Once we got behind it became a comedy of errors, injuries and lost our structure.

Complete opposite to when we got behind in the Warriors game (where we held our nerve amd just kept kicking to corners etc)
 

Gibs

Great White
Joined
May 20, 2009
Messages
2,799
Reaction score
31
Location
Yarrawarrah
There were multiple times where the ball hit the deck and we all just stood around watching it. One time API recovered it for the Tigers. It was embarrassing.
 

Gards

Jaws
Joined
Apr 25, 2010
Messages
18,369
Reaction score
1,914
Location
At the Tucky
View attachment 30667Stolen off Facebook but…

What this tells me is that losing to the Tigers is so emotionally damaging and embarrassing that the team makes a pack to go all the way to make up for the shame

How the Sharks can make the GF when they can't beat top 8 or bottom 8 teams is beyond me though o_O:rolleyes:

Maybe if 15 other teams get done for salary cap rorting
 

Steve Kneen

Grey Nurse
Joined
Apr 30, 2006
Messages
638
Reaction score
47
You are not understanding the rule there obviously.

The doctor calls HIA not because he got a pinky on the chin but because he laid motionless then got up grabbing his head. The doctor does not give a **** about legal or illegal contact, its about the players condition post contact.

The referee in the bunker can only intervene if the contact is reportable. If you think that brush on the face is worthy of going on report im implore you to stop watching the game.

If a sharks player was put on report for that, id be filthy.

Taking dives is rife in the sport. Gutho, Moses, Rapana, Mulitalo and even Ponga wjo grabs his head every tackle are the leaders in it. If you wanna play hurt, the doctor will take you off for a HIA.
You're clueless.

It just goes to show that you have some sort of attention deficit when it comes to Rugby League observations. "Pinky on the chin" you said.
I am not asserting the match review committee are always right, but in this case they are, and Sutton and Butler should be demoted, pair of dh's. Now do what you said, and "stop watching the game".

Wests Tigers pair Stefano Utoikamanu & Api Koroisau have accepted early guilty pleas after being charged for an incident in Saturday's victory over Cronulla Sharks. Both Koroisau and Utoikamanu were hit with a Grade 1 Dangerous Contact charge for a tackle they were both involved in, on Sharks forward Toby Rudolf
 

Gards

Jaws
Joined
Apr 25, 2010
Messages
18,369
Reaction score
1,914
Location
At the Tucky
Putting in and hanging in there for the first 15 mins then falling to pieces is some serious John Morris era bullshit, the sort of thing I would hope be behind this team by now.

It also concerns me that we are still capable of turning up like that and getting blown off the park. Penrith don't win every single game they play but they rarely get destroyed like we do a few times a year now at least. It's not typically at the hands of a team like the Tigers though but usually a genuine top 8 contender that puts the cleaners through us.

Penrith are always in the game even when they play bad.

Panthers bad is no where near our bad. Expectations are much higher at that club as is accountability. They have an assembly line of talent waiting in the wings to take someones place if they **** the bed and their coach doesn't get played for a fool. When we get destroyed coach just shrugs and says yea I dunno - yea well he should know.

I would have been ok with the errors ect, heck even a loss if we had shown the energy, defense and attitude of the first 2 weeks to hang in an turn them away while we work on getting better with the ball later in the game but it scares me how quick that mindset seemed to evaporate.

I struggle to believe the Tigers were that good with the ball to blow us away like that but it makes we feel like maybe our D hasn't improved as much as I had hoped and that the first 2 rounds had shown. Sometimes teams are gunna come from no where and ambush you, we need to be ready for that and handle it better when it happens.

Dunno if I want it to be more an attitude thing or a structural thing cause we have struggled with addressing both post Flanno.

I agree with BWB, we did not need a loss or a lesson, especially not this early in the season as we are just building our campaign. We needed the 2 points in a game we had every right to show up with our heads on and take them.

We have had enough lessons and getting embarrassed like that is only going to serve to motivate us and improve us for the next game. The bounce back factor isn't going to sustain us long term or carry us deep into the season, it can help us against the Raiders while it's still fresh and stings but I don't see any long term benefits beyond this coming weekend to dropping those 2 points and we are still only 50/50 to beat the Raiders.

If it was our first loss like that yea sure maybe some long term lessons to take onboard for the long term good about but the last few years have shown me we are slow learners when it comes to complacency so why will it be any different this time?

If Dale and Cam want to prove their worth as on field and off field leaders at this club, lay down the law with your fellow players, you blokes are the captains tell them that was not acceptable, not was some rank BS and it WILL NOT happen again under their watch.

Gallen had to cop this sort of thing on the chin back in the day cause we had no money and no players but that is no longer the case. Alot of time, effort and resources have gone into turning this club around and building it towards long term success on and off the field.

The players have to do their part in living the culture and setting the standards of what putting on that Sharks jersey means. It's no good just talking about it and doing it for 2 rounds, you gotta meet that responsibility and expectation week in week out.

I get that this was just 1 game and there is an entire season ahead but it is still 1 game that shouldn't really happen if we are serious. The tigers are a team and club that will be doing well to even push for a finals birth and I know we are not silly enough to think we are already there and a lock for the top 8 but we are a better team than them. It wasn't the Panthers that dusted us, that's almost expected.

But if we make the finals again (which we should) are we gunna turn up and do another round 3 Tigers on ourselves?

Spose our good run of beating up the cellar dweller teams had to come to an end sometime but I wish it wasn't like that.
 

Wilson

Great White
Joined
Apr 20, 2009
Messages
3,090
Reaction score
534
Putting in and hanging in there for the first 15 mins then falling to pieces is some serious John Morris era bullshit, the sort of thing I would hope be behind this team by now.

It also concerns me that we are still capable of turning up like that and getting blown off the park. Penrith don't win every single game they play but they rarely get destroyed like we do a few times a year now at least. It's not typically at the hands of a team like the Tigers though but usually a genuine top 8 contender that puts the cleaners through us.

Penrith are always in the game even when they play bad.

Panthers bad is no where near our bad. Expectations are much higher at that club as is accountability. They have an assembly line of talent waiting in the wings to take someones place if they **** the bed and their coach doesn't get played for a fool. When we get destroyed coach just shrugs and says yea I dunno - yea well he should know.

I would have been ok with the errors ect, heck even a loss if we had shown the energy, defense and attitude of the first 2 weeks to hang in an turn them away while we work on getting better with the ball later in the game but it scares me how quick that mindset seemed to evaporate.

I struggle to believe the Tigers were that good with the ball to blow us away like that but it makes we feel like maybe our D hasn't improved as much as I had hoped and that the first 2 rounds had shown. Sometimes teams are gunna come from no where and ambush you, we need to be ready for that and handle it better when it happens.

Dunno if I want it to be more an attitude thing or a structural thing cause we have struggled with addressing both post Flanno.

I agree with BWB, we did not need a loss or a lesson, especially not this early in the season as we are just building our campaign. We needed the 2 points in a game we had every right to show up with our heads on and take them.

We have had enough lessons and getting embarrassed like that is only going to serve to motivate us and improve us for the next game. The bounce back factor isn't going to sustain us long term or carry us deep into the season, it can help us against the Raiders while it's still fresh and stings but I don't see any long term benefits beyond this coming weekend to dropping those 2 points and we are still only 50/50 to beat the Raiders.

If it was our first loss like that yea sure maybe some long term lessons to take onboard for the long term good about but the last few years have shown me we are slow learners when it comes to complacency so why will it be any different this time?

If Dale and Cam want to prove their worth as on field and off field leaders at this club, lay down the law with your fellow players, you blokes are the captains tell them that was not acceptable, not was some rank BS and it WILL NOT happen again under their watch.

Gallen had to cop this sort of thing on the chin back in the day cause we had no money and no players but that is no longer the case. Alot of time, effort and resources have gone into turning this club around and building it towards long term success on and off the field.

The players have to do their part in living the culture and setting the standards of what putting on that Sharks jersey means. It's no good just talking about it and doing it for 2 rounds, you gotta meet that responsibility and expectation week in week out.

I get that this was just 1 game and there is an entire season ahead but it is still 1 game that shouldn't really happen if we are serious. The tigers are a team and club that will be doing well to even push for a finals birth and I know we are not silly enough to think we are already there and a lock for the top 8 but we are a better team than them. It wasn't the Panthers that dusted us, that's almost expected.

But if we make the finals again (which we should) are we gunna turn up and do another round 3 Tigers on ourselves?

Spose our good run of beating up the cellar dweller teams had to come to an end sometime but I wish it wasn't like that.
Your posts are far too long.
 

Sparkles

Jaws
Joined
May 21, 2008
Messages
12,045
Reaction score
2,780
Same here.

But the players should be made to watch it, over and over again.

I was wondering too with all the talk about complacency - did we actually go into the game knowing it would be tough and we would have to turn up and then thought we had it won easily when Tom scored his try. From all reports, the first 10-15 minutes wasn't that bad but after Tom's try we turned to ****.
I did watch Ghostbusters... It was awesome
 
Top