2010 Four Nations General Discussion

[Ibanez]

It said he and Gidley will be the utilities, I would much rather carney on the bench than Gids at the moment.

lol.

 

[josh11223344]

what?

 

[bort]

Gidlol?

 

[Mr Wright]

1. Slater
2. Boyd
3. Jennings
4. Inglis
5. Morris
6. Lockyer
7. Thurston
8. Petro
9. Smith
10. Shillington
11. Thaiday
12. Watmough
13. Gallen

14. Myles
15. Hannant
16. Snowden
17. Cronk

Tough to leave Hayne out, but I'd rather have Morris and Boyd who will play good/great every game where as you take a massive risk on Hayne either having a blinder or a shocker. Granted the chance he ****s it up in an Aussie team is far less than the chances he has a shocker for Parra, I still wouldn't pick him.

 

[snowman]

too much blue in the team, needs all the maroon flavour it can get

 

[A.Snowden]

too much blue in the team, needs all the maroon flavour it can get

:No::No::No::No::No:

 

[snowman]

5 years of dominance says we should have more maroon in the team

 

[A.Snowden]

There is enough there mate, but i can't see Jennings being there, Thurston is doubtfull but Cronk will slot in there, Would love to see Kade get a run, but i don't know...

 

[snowman]

the team should be

1 slater
2 boyd
3 inglis
4 lyon
5 hayne
6 lockyer
7 thurston/cronk
8 petro
9 smith
10 shillington
11 myles
12 thiaday
13 gallen

14 cronk/gidley
14 lewis
16 scott/hannant
17 snow/douglas

18 carney
19 ash harrison
20 watmong
21 snow/douglas
22 scott/hannant
23 willie tonga

 

[A.Snowden]

That will most likely be close to the mark in my opinion

 

[Sharky Pete]

the team should be

1 slater
2 boyd
3 inglis
4 lyon
5 hayne
6 lockyer
7 thurston/cronk
8 petro
9 smith
10 shillington
11 myles
12 thiaday
13 gallen

14 cronk/gidley
14 lewis
16 scott/hannant
17 snow/douglas

18 carney
19 ash harrison
20 watmong
21 snow/douglas
22 scott/hannant
23 willie tonga

I'd have Snowy ahead of Shillington tbh.

Snowy has been brilliant for us all season.

I think he is a better player than Shillington is.

 

[snowman]

shillingtons origin form, and the form in the last 6 weeks has been better than snowies.
he gets the nod, snow a bench spot

 

[Jigsaw]

Shillington is the form prop of the NRL, he will be one of the first players picked for an Australian jersey. To ignore this is just one eyed dribble

 

[A.Snowden]

Spot on. He has been in great form and no doubt be one of the first picked, but on origin form i would like to think TLL will get a mention. I would still love to see Kade get a run though

 

[snowman]

lockyer will be first picked

forgot TLL, he will get a spot

 

[ABshark]

too much blue in the team, needs all the maroon flavour it can get

I don't get this. Why do should the national selectors pick along state lines (and I know they do)? Why not just pick the best 17?

Jennings and Lyon are the next best/most dangerous centres after Gringles (Given the Folau situ). Morris is the best winger. Gal one of the best 2 back rowers. TLL's in great form, he will be on the bench.

Anyway, if NSW had Thurston and Lockyer, it would have been 5-0 the other way.

 

[snowman]

yeh but you dont, and 5 years of dominance should be rewarded, and brett morris should be no where near the national team, he was **** in origin and **** now

 

[ABshark]

You're rewarded by winning the series. Origin isn't a drawn out trial for the national side- as is shown every year by the number of blokes they pick from the GF sides who didn't play Origin.

F*** rugby league is way too political.

 

[snowman]

if you want to reward people on club form, ben creagh will be the captain.
i would have a look at how they play rep football

 

[josh11223344]

what about Uate he would have to be a big shot? It's been 2 years since he represented Fiji so he'll be eligiible.