HaroldBishop
Megalodon
KinkyDidn't think he was a Nicho style half... There you go. Ask Sir Chadley to slip that into Fitz's inbox please
KinkyDidn't think he was a Nicho style half... There you go. Ask Sir Chadley to slip that into Fitz's inbox please
Agree with this and don't see why his pre 2022 form is even relevant. It's about what he can do now.moses has been above "mid" since 2018
Not as kinky as The Punisher's junk folderKinky
Moylan is not the future and with him we get no closer to the trophy.It is actually embarrassing when Moylan kicks the ball - and as a whole - we are under par in the kicking game ..
I agree re Moylan not being the future.Moylan is not the future and with him we get no closer to the trophy.
We lose nothing without him, give another half (Trindall eg) a run for the year if it works it works happy days if it doesn’t then we lose nothing and could go to market with no overheads at all instead of over investing in nothingness in the other halves spot
Trindall is a happy go lucky kid who is a late maturer in the mental sense. He will come good with the right coaching.I agree re Moylan not being the future.
But you lost me at Trindell..
Would rather Moyza over him
Reckon he'd go well at the Dolphins.Trindall is a happy go lucky kid who is a late maturer in the mental sense. He will come good with the right coaching.
For when?Im still perplexed how we dont have room in the cap with our current squad
I still don’t get the 2 years for Moylan - I could live with 1 year - it’s not like his door was being bashed down ..Moylan is not the future and with him we get no closer to the trophy.
We lose nothing without him, give another half (Trindall eg) a run for the year if it works it works happy days if it doesn’t then we lose nothing and could go to market with no overheads at all instead of over investing in nothingness in the other halves spot
Yeah I'm not happy about that. For sure he would have wanted more than one year but we should have stood firm. If he leaves, he leaves.I still don’t get the 2 years for Moylan - I could live with 1 year - it’s not like his door was being bashed down ..
And we have Trindall/Hynes pairing - no thanks.Yeah I'm not happy about that. For sure he would have wanted more than one year but we should have stood firm. If he leaves, he leaves.
thing is, 2 years locks us in to moylan with no get outAnd we have Trindall/Hynes pairing - no thanks.
I'd rather the extra year if it meant keeping Moylan and giving us time to recruit/replace him - whether it's that Penrith kid, Dykes, Rivett who knows. Gives us time to plan.
Do we know Moylan's 2nd year dollars? It's pretty feasible that he takes a Wade style role in our halves depth for 2024 (and next year wouldn't hurt).thing is, 2 years locks us in to moylan with no get out
we could have given him a 1 year deal, no one else wanted him
now, if rivett, dykes, the penrith kid all kill it we have more dead cap, we also have to look to move him on if we had a shot at someone like moses
his contract is apparently very user friendly both years, but still, there was no bidding war for himDo we know Moylan's 2nd year dollars? It's pretty feasible that he takes a Wade style role in our halves depth for 2024 (and next year wouldn't hurt).
If the bucks aren't too big and we've planned to give someone else a run then 2 years is fine. If Moylan's the only one getting a look-in it's a bad move.
Bennet is the best man manager in the league.Reckon he'd go well at the Dolphins.
yeh no issue with moylan in 2022, he was one of our better players, but he is probably the one we need to upgradeI know that we'd like him to kick more, and a handful of posters don't like the guy - but Moylan can't have done too much wrong in the eyes of the forum in 2022. At one point he won 4 MoMs in a row in the 3-2-1 didn't he?
The main issue we've had with Moylan from 2019-21 is that he gets injured too much, and that he plays like **** in his first game or two back from injury. Neither of those things happened in 2022. I for one would take 2022 Moylan over any version of Shaun Johnson who turned out in a Sharks jersey.