snowman
Total gronk
Not even a single for SJ? rough
Any one know who was our games judge?
they dont publish the judges after ruan sims copped it big time last year
Not even a single for SJ? rough
Any one know who was our games judge?
He had a little bit of a point when it comes to it is all well and good for SJ to tear up weaker teams, but you are supposed to score that game as a standalone.
No way SJ wasn't top 3 Sharks player from that game as a standalone. Brailey was pretty good for 52 minutes but I can't say he was better than Johnson. Everyone bar 1 in this thread has voted SJ for 3 I think (ironically they gave Brailey the 3)
I'm still torn who to give my 1 vote to but Johnson has my 3 too
they dont publish the judges after ruan sims copped it big time last year
He had a little bit of a point when it comes to it is all well and good for SJ to tear up weaker teams, but you are supposed to score that game as a standalone.
No way SJ wasn't top 3 Sharks player from that game as a standalone. Brailey was pretty good for 52 minutes but I can't say he was better than Johnson. Everyone bar 1 in this thread has voted SJ for 3 I think (ironically they gave Brailey the 3)
I'm still torn who to give my 1 vote to but Johnson has my 3 too
It’s all good for cooper- he played in star studded teams under a super coach his whole career- this is the strongest side Sj has ever played in.
I found the whole thing a bit weird and premeditated tbh- he carried on before the game how Sj had to step up then he carves up and cronk still gives it to him.
It was all a bit weird but made headlines so I guess it done it’s job.
the other solution to that problem would be just get more reliable judges, but I guess not publishing them is easier.
SJ has 56% of the fan vote on the sharks members player of the week too so seems a pretty solid consensus from the non experts he was worth a point
the other solution to that problem would be just get more reliable judges, but I guess not publishing them is easier.
SJ has 56% of the fan vote on the sharks members player of the week too so seems a pretty solid consensus from the non experts he was worth a point
SJ has way more social media followers than most other Sharks to, who'd be way more active online. Not sure I'd read too much into the fan votes mate
Did he share it via his social media?
Not saying if he has more votes there it must be true, just saying it's another point of data that supports our votes here and a lot of comments also on places like reddit that feel like he should have got a Dally M vote.
If anything the Sharks one actually has an award from the club so it counts for more than what we think in the end
Just saying that his groupies (what was it, 3x more than any other Shark?) are probably digitally savvy and pretty active, so I don't think sharing it would matter if it's a fan vote. You know, like how Guy Sebastian's brother wins The Voice. Like that.
They should have a panel of 3 judges who come to a 3,2,1 score. And they do every game of the season. That way it'll be consistent.
Always found the voting odd.
SJ should be atop the ladder.
JUST CHQD
Panji jnr never got any votes after getting channel 9 MOM