Official William Kennedy

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member T1
  • Start date Start date
AdShark said:
4 errors
2 hospital passes that lead to an error for stonestreet and one for hiroti
His 1 try assist (don’t think I didn’t notice that sneaky little attempt to pump him up) was 4 metres forward and very lucky not to be called back.

Worthy of man of the match? Absolutely not. Only people giving him that only watched the highlights

Woeful performance

Any other player there’d be a mob in here ready for them
Click to expand...
What do you mean any other player? He is constantly getting followed around by forum members holding pitch forks!
 
AdShark said:
4 errors
2 hospital passes that lead to an error for stonestreet and one for hiroti
His 1 try assist (don’t think I didn’t notice that sneaky little attempt to pump him up) was 4 metres forward and very lucky not to be called back.

Worthy of man of the match? Absolutely not. Only people giving him that only watched the highlights

Woeful performance

Any other player there’d be a mob in here ready for them
Click to expand...
I never said he was man of the match. I didn’t give him any points in my 321s.

The bit I have put in bold, how do you know that? That’s a big assumption considering you’ve never seen what they’re watching.

Not sure why you have a big chip on your shoulder about this. His try assist four metres forward? You were right in line to see the pass were you? If you watch the replay, the pass definitely goes backwards out of his hands. And it wasn’t a sneaky attempt at all by me to include the try assist and I was not trying to pump him up. I was just saying apart from the errors he made he did some good things too.
 
Sir Chadley said:
I never said he was man of the match. I didn’t give him any points in my 321s.

The bit I have put in bold, how do you know that? That’s a big assumption considering you’ve never seen what they’re watching.

Not sure why you have a big chip on your shoulder about this. His try assist four metres forward? You were right in line to see the pass were you? If you watch the replay, the pass definitely goes backwards out of his hands. And it wasn’t a sneaky attempt at all by me to include the try assist and I was not trying to pump him up. I was just saying apart from the errors he made he did some good things too.
Click to expand...
Blind Freddy could see it was forward
 
Good game overall despite a few uncharacteristic errors.
In the first half, the team was completely off and Will didn't set himself apart.

That one-handed pickup was pure class though.
 
Sir Chadley said:
I never said he was man of the match. I didn’t give him any points in my 321s.

The bit I have put in bold, how do you know that? That’s a big assumption considering you’ve never seen what they’re watching.

Not sure why you have a big chip on your shoulder about this. His try assist four metres forward? You were right in line to see the pass were you? If you watch the replay, the pass definitely goes backwards out of his hands. And it wasn’t a sneaky attempt at all by me to include the try assist and I was not trying to pump him up. I was just saying apart from the errors he made he did some good things too.
Click to expand...
Never said you did. But you did make up stats to try and defend him.

And that pass was very forward if you take off your black, white and blue glasses.

And I have to assume that’s what they watched because if not. They’re taking the Mickey out of the votes
 
AdShark said:
Truth hurts hey?
Click to expand...

Nah I just don’t like people who think their opinion is the be all and end all and if you don’t agree with said opinion, you’re taking the mickey.

You think he had a bad game. Others, including myself think he had a good game. There are stats that back up both viewpoints. So you go to peoples eye tests, which is never fully reliable on either side, we’re just average fans at the end of the day, we don’t see everything. So it comes to just a matter of opinion. People aren’t taking the mickey just because they don't agree with your opinion.
 
AdShark said:
Never said you did. But you did make up stats to try and defend him.

And that pass was very forward if you take off your black, white and blue glasses.

And I have to assume that’s what they watched because if not. They’re taking the Mickey out of the votes
Click to expand...
I completely agree the pass was forward. I called it live too, but that's footy, it was close enough he got away with it. He was involved in two oher tries too, contributing to half our points. I thought he put his body on the line to stop the potential holmes try that Ronnie grounded, and also contributed to some good early shifts out of our end.

A number of forgettable moments too which you've covered, and for that reason he didn't factor into my top 3. Wasn't his best game, but it was a long way from woeful IMO.

Generally most fans vote regarding who generated the most points/attack. Will was certainly up there for that.
 
Proud Shark said:
I completely agree the pass was forward. I called it live too, but that's footy, it was close enough he got away with it. He was involved in two oher tries too, contributing to half our points. I thought he put his body on the line to stop the potential holmes try that Ronnie grounded, and also contributed to some good early shifts out of our end.

A number of forgettable moments too which you've covered, and for that reason he didn't factor into my top 3. Wasn't his best game, but it was a long way from woeful IMO.

Generally most fans vote regarding who generated the most points/attack. Will was certainly up there for that.
Click to expand...
Will was probably over involved in the bad start
And over involved in the good stuff
So can take that either way I guess.

I will say, contested kicks are never a sure thing, not like they were clean drops.
And the offload attempt and pass to SS were trying to push attack, which those critical of him say he doesn’t offer enough threat. If you want someone like Walsh or Drinky you’d see plenty of similar errors.
 
AdShark said:
Never said you did. But you did make up stats to try and defend him.

And that pass was very forward if you take off your black, white and blue glasses.

And I have to assume that’s what they watched because if not. They’re taking the Mickey out of the votes
Click to expand...
I don’t make up stats mate, that’s a ridiculous thing for you to say.

I won’t say any more as @CrazyMatt and @Proud Shark covered it nicely.
 
bort said:
Will was probably over involved in the bad start
And over involved in the good stuff
So can take that either way I guess.

I will say, contested kicks are never a sure thing, not like they were clean drops.
And the offload attempt and pass to SS were trying to push attack, which those critical of him say he doesn’t offer enough threat. If you want someone like Walsh or Drinky you’d see plenty of similar errors.
Click to expand...
Yeah wasn't his best night diffusing kicks. I normally wouldn't mind pushing that pass, but with 2 minutes or so to go when we were gassed it just wasn't on. I think it was Egan who read it well enough to force the error. He was great for them.
 
Proud Shark said:
Yeah wasn't his best night diffusing kicks. I normally wouldn't mind pushing that pass, but with 2 minutes or so to go when we were gassed it just wasn't on. I think it was Egan who read it well enough to force the error. He was great for them.
Click to expand...
Yeah he belted SS as he caught it. It wasn't a bad pass, was just into contact, every chance Ronnie catches it and could even have been a chance to beat the contact. Different story with SS, can't win a contact with a headstart, so it wasn't on.

Egan, Stewart and the Couchman's are a great, hard working young core for them, and why they have managed to hang in games early at times, even if Dargs overall quality wasn't there.
 
bort said:
Yeah he belted SS as he caught it. It wasn't a bad pass, was just into contact, every chance Ronnie catches it and could even have been a chance to beat the contact. Different story with SS, can't win a contact with a headstart, so it wasn't on.

Egan, Stewart and the Couchman's are a great, hard working young core for them, and why they have managed to hang in games early at times, even if Dargs overall quality wasn't there.
Click to expand...

Give those kids a couple years they'll be the best pack in the comp.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top