BurgoShark
Super Moderator
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2008
- Messages
- 12,868
- Reaction score
- 4,094
OK - sure - please do. It would be much more useful than you quoting fantasy stats
PODCAST Thread
- Thread starter egg
- Start date
D
Deleted member 28437
Guest
OK - sure - please do. It would be much more useful than you quoting fantasy stats
Yep great will do. Good to know who the stat police is here anyway. Enjoy your evening.
snowman
Total gronk
says the spoofer who got caught out in the mcinnes thread for making up fantasy scenariosOK - sure - please do. It would be much more useful than you quoting fantasy stats
Wilson
Great White
- Joined
- Apr 20, 2009
- Messages
- 3,089
- Reaction score
- 527
In other words - I want to be the only stats stooge here buckoOK - sure - please do. It would be much more useful than you quoting fantasy stats
BurgoShark
Super Moderator
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2008
- Messages
- 12,868
- Reaction score
- 4,094
You do realize that all the work I've done with stats is to show that you can compare players who have different usage/deployment - right?
Not the stat police... but if you want to make a point of comparing players, use players who are playing the same role and the same minutes.
"Per 80" is definitely a much better way to do it than "per game", but I think you need to exclude guys who play less than say, 60 minutes in an average game, or guys who also play as running forwards.
D
Deleted member 28437
Guest
Ok, understood. Let's move on.
Wiz
Jaws
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2016
- Messages
- 5,906
- Reaction score
- 1,514
Who deleted gav89 ?
snowman
Total gronk
probably burgo because he got shown up
HaroldBishop
Megalodon
Can we please have a graph for how many users have been deleted?
Wiz
Jaws
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2016
- Messages
- 5,906
- Reaction score
- 1,514
Burg ? Is this true
Sparkles
Jaws
- Joined
- May 21, 2008
- Messages
- 12,038
- Reaction score
- 2,771
Looks like he moved on
Milkshark
Great White
- Joined
- Jul 16, 2012
- Messages
- 4,750
- Reaction score
- 532
Good podcast Snowman. Enjoyed seeing your guys point of view.
I agree on replacing Hunt. It feels like every year he plays, he needs just 1 more year to fulfill the potential he has. But then the next year comes along and his still 1 year off his breakout year. He might spend more time in the weights room in pre season than actually working on his game.
Does the Sharks lack a captain? And who is the future captain?
The club without Graham is definitely missing leadership. The inot issue when Graham is back, he will be lucky to be playing off the bench, which is not where you want your captain to be. There might be an argument just to slot him in at 12 next to Moylan just for his defence if Fits is going to persevere with Moylan.
I would agree giving Hynes captain today could only be done if Hynes actually personally asked for it. Otherwise I really think that is putting too much pressure on him when he is still transitioning into a pure 7. He has the respect the players, the staff, the media and can back it all up with on field performance’s.
When can we give an honest opinion on Fitz?
I think Fitz definitely benefited from an easy draw last year, with a breakout year from Hynes at 7. So far this year, Hynes is looking strong again, and we have another easy draw. But we are dropping games that are easily winnable.
Fitz is loyal which in turn means he is also stubborn. Being loyal is a admirable trait, but in this game, if being loyal means you stubbornly continue to pick players that are costing you wins, you will soon be out of favour and out of a job.
Now is the time to put Trindall in at 6. Give give him 2 full weeks training there and try come create some unison with Hynes. I don’t think you said but the other guy on the podcast, If Trindall doesn’t play well against the Roosters, drop him and out Moylan back in. That is not the way. You put him at 6 and be done with it.
There will be games where Trindall has off days, he will over cook something, make errors. But the alternative is doing the same ole and leaving Moylan in and leaking trys and metres in that left side.
On what purpose is Trindall picked on the bench?
If I was picking the team and I put Trindall on the bench, it would be injury cover for Moylan / Hynes, which I don’t agree on picking players on the bench just in case.
Or maybe giving Brailey a 20 minute spell. I don’t like that idea either, Trindall isn’t a hooker and he doesn’t have utility value.
Trindall is a starting 6/7 or he isn’t in the 17.
On Ronnie and his chirp
I agree it’s part of his game, and I don’t want him to reel it in. But I do want him to be more conscious of when chirping helps you and the team, and when it doesn’t help the team. If you’re scoring trys, winning and on top, sure chirp away. But if the other team has it over you and your ego is too big that you need to laugh and rub oppositions heads or whatever, you’re only giving them motivation.
I have a lot of time for Ronnie, he does alot off the field and I respect him so highly for that. I just want him have a bit more class on the field.
I will listen to the rest of the podcast today and provide more feedback.
I agree on replacing Hunt. It feels like every year he plays, he needs just 1 more year to fulfill the potential he has. But then the next year comes along and his still 1 year off his breakout year. He might spend more time in the weights room in pre season than actually working on his game.
Does the Sharks lack a captain? And who is the future captain?
The club without Graham is definitely missing leadership. The inot issue when Graham is back, he will be lucky to be playing off the bench, which is not where you want your captain to be. There might be an argument just to slot him in at 12 next to Moylan just for his defence if Fits is going to persevere with Moylan.
I would agree giving Hynes captain today could only be done if Hynes actually personally asked for it. Otherwise I really think that is putting too much pressure on him when he is still transitioning into a pure 7. He has the respect the players, the staff, the media and can back it all up with on field performance’s.
When can we give an honest opinion on Fitz?
I think Fitz definitely benefited from an easy draw last year, with a breakout year from Hynes at 7. So far this year, Hynes is looking strong again, and we have another easy draw. But we are dropping games that are easily winnable.
Fitz is loyal which in turn means he is also stubborn. Being loyal is a admirable trait, but in this game, if being loyal means you stubbornly continue to pick players that are costing you wins, you will soon be out of favour and out of a job.
Now is the time to put Trindall in at 6. Give give him 2 full weeks training there and try come create some unison with Hynes. I don’t think you said but the other guy on the podcast, If Trindall doesn’t play well against the Roosters, drop him and out Moylan back in. That is not the way. You put him at 6 and be done with it.
There will be games where Trindall has off days, he will over cook something, make errors. But the alternative is doing the same ole and leaving Moylan in and leaking trys and metres in that left side.
On what purpose is Trindall picked on the bench?
If I was picking the team and I put Trindall on the bench, it would be injury cover for Moylan / Hynes, which I don’t agree on picking players on the bench just in case.
Or maybe giving Brailey a 20 minute spell. I don’t like that idea either, Trindall isn’t a hooker and he doesn’t have utility value.
Trindall is a starting 6/7 or he isn’t in the 17.
On Ronnie and his chirp
I agree it’s part of his game, and I don’t want him to reel it in. But I do want him to be more conscious of when chirping helps you and the team, and when it doesn’t help the team. If you’re scoring trys, winning and on top, sure chirp away. But if the other team has it over you and your ego is too big that you need to laugh and rub oppositions heads or whatever, you’re only giving them motivation.
I have a lot of time for Ronnie, he does alot off the field and I respect him so highly for that. I just want him have a bit more class on the field.
I will listen to the rest of the podcast today and provide more feedback.
Last edited:
Not being loyal to a player who isn’t playing well went out the window pretty quick when it was a player you like you were talking about.
Once Trindall does get a crack he does deserve some opportunity to warm into the role, but if he keeps costing us wins I think you’ll find Moylan might get another crack.
(Before we get too worried about bort defending Moylan again I’ve already said I’d like to see Trindall come in after the bye)
Ronnie
Bronze Whaler
- Joined
- Mar 29, 2023
- Messages
- 85
- Reaction score
- 75
I’ve got Trindall at 6
McInnes at 13
Uele and Hunt at props
Williams, Graham, kaufusi, hazelton bench
For the talk about Hazelton needing to prove himself I think it’s BHU and Hunt that need to do the proving against the chooks. They are meant to be tough guys. McInnes has also gone backwards this year and needs to step up. If they’re **** al least we know for sure.
McInnes at 13
Uele and Hunt at props
Williams, Graham, kaufusi, hazelton bench
For the talk about Hazelton needing to prove himself I think it’s BHU and Hunt that need to do the proving against the chooks. They are meant to be tough guys. McInnes has also gone backwards this year and needs to step up. If they’re **** al least we know for sure.
D
Deleted member 3365
Guest
We need to be playing McInnes like how the Rabbits use Murray, Roosters use Radley, how the Storm used B.Smith.
Ball playing lock, rather than barge over. Finucane can go prop.
Ball playing lock, rather than barge over. Finucane can go prop.
Sparkles
Jaws
- Joined
- May 21, 2008
- Messages
- 12,038
- Reaction score
- 2,771
I feel like he was doing that when he first joined but changed this year
beaver2233
Tiger Shark
- Joined
- May 7, 2022
- Messages
- 1,140
- Reaction score
- 604
Haven't listened to it yet, but podcast from Six to Go with Josh Hannay.
open.spotify.com
Episode 25- Josh Hannay
Listen to this episode from Six To Go on Spotify. With the Cronulla Sharks on a bye, assistant coach Josh Hannay joined me to break down their first 5 weeks of the year. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
open.spotify.com
Six To Go: Episode 25- Josh Hannay on Apple Podcasts
Show Six To Go, Ep Episode 25- Josh Hannay - 6 Apr 2023
podcasts.apple.com