NRL's Most Overrated Players 3-2-1

[egg]

Just some fun , who are your three most overrated players .
Maybe collate results in a fortnight.


3, Darius Boyd ( not worth his salary )
2. Ben Hunt ( not worth his salary )
1. Clint Gutherson

 

[HaroldBishop]

I don't think anyone rates Darius these days, Egg.

 

[HaroldBishop]

Anyway, if you're going to base on salary, without giving it too much thought I would go with.

Moylan
Hunt
Johnson

 

[egg]

Anyway, if you're going to base on salary, without giving it too much thought I would go with.

Moylan
Hunt
Johnson

Maybe shouldn't be solely base on salary , I just used that as part of my reasoning .
I wonder if overrated or bad value correlate .

 

[snowman]

chad
fkn
townsend

 

[egg]

chad
fkn
townsend

, I though he might get a mention

 

[Western Sharkie]

3. Braith Anasta
2. Braith Anasta
1. Braith Anasta

 

[Gards]

Pretty much half the blokes the Blues used to name in their Origin teams

 

[stormshark]

3 Falou
2 Vagana
1 Hess

 

[Flanno]

Some of the lads I find a bit overrated, ignoring Sharks players:

Gavin Cooper, Ben Hunt, James Roberts, Leilua, J Brailey, Ash Taylor, Peats

 

[vicsharkfan]

In no order, ( and leaving sharks out) and maybe all in their prime I may not have chosen them. But anyways

Hunt

Jennings- harsh maybe always had speed but jeez he seems to be nothing but a ball hog now.

Chambers- although I love him for not seeing a unmarked Cronk on the inside 2nd October 2016 @ approx 9.20pm

I was going to go Milford somewhere in there as well, to me the hype or $$$ just don’t match the output of these 4.

 

[Snaggletooth]

3. Mitch Aubesson - very overrated but a great ‘clubman’ apparently
2. Boyd Cordner - credit to him though, ordinary player who has won premierships, SOO series, captained Australia
1. Dane Gagai - kind of marquee player Sharks will buy in massive overpayment

 

[Super Impose]

3. Mitch Aubesson - very overrated but a great ‘clubman’ apparently
2. Boyd Cordner - credit to him though, ordinary player who has won premierships, SOO series, captained Australia
1. Dane Gagai - kind of marquee player Sharks will buy in massive overpayment

With regard to Gagai - he produces so much in origin and so little at club level.

 

[sharks for life]

Shannon Boyd
Kerian foran
Matt dickfigers moylan

 

[HaroldBishop]

3. Mitch Aubesson - very overrated but a great ‘clubman’ apparently
2. Boyd Cordner - credit to him though, ordinary player who has won premierships, SOO series, captained Australia
1. Dane Gagai - kind of marquee player Sharks will buy in massive overpayment

I like Aubesson, don't see him as overrated.

 

[CrazyMatt]

3. Milford
2. Gagai
1. Hunt

All very much overpaid and they under deliver.

 

[Tatus]

Shannon Boyd
Kerian foran
Matt dickfigers moylan

Foran would have to top my list. How he got a gig at the dogs and warriors on such big coin after what happened is beyond me. I’ll try find some stats later to compare him and Moylan

 

[may]

Boyd cordner
Michael Morgan
Jake Friend

 

[bort]

I like Aubesson, don't see him as overrated.

As if a grand final winning 7 could ever be overrated

 

[Western Sharkie]

As if a grand final winning 7 could ever be overrated

I sense sarcasm in that post bort!