Cronulla vs Warriors, NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008

Status
Not open for further replies.

SF

Mako Shark
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
9,862
Reaction score
1,367
Location
Monty Porter Stand
This is the ratings thread for the match:

Warriors 18 - Cronulla 4
NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008
Mt Smart Stadium, 5:30 pm, Saturday August 16, 2008


To add your ratings and/or comments, please
fill out the form on the match review page.

  • Filling in the above form allows the average ratings to be automatically calculated, and your comments added to this thread (you can't post in this thread directly).
  • Please login before voting if you want to have your votes recorded under your username.
  • Ratings are open for a period of two weeks after the match.
  • Only one vote per IP address/username is allowed.
  • Ratings and comments are optional for all players. You can rate as many or as few as you would like. However, you can't go back and add/edit ratings after you vote.
  • The ratings results for this match are also available on the match review page once you have voted (or skipped voting).
  • The ratings leaderboard for this season is available here.
  • The all-time ratings results for this grade/competition are available here.
 

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
29,394
Reaction score
5,517
Location
IN A BAR
bort's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 6
2. Misi Taulapapa - 6
3. Ben Pomeroy - 6
4. David Simmons - 7
5. Luke Covell - 6
6. Brett Seymour - 5
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
8. Ben Ross - 6
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Paul Gallen - 6
12. Fraser Anderson - 5
15. Grant Millington - 6
14. Danny Nutley - 5
13. Greg Bird - 7
16. Adam Peek - 6
17. Terence Seu Seu - 6

WARRIORS:
1. Wade McKinnon - 7
2. Malo Solomona - 6
3. Brent Tate - 6
4. Jerome Ropati - 8
5. Manu Vatuvei - 8
6. Michael Witt - 7
7. Nathan Fien - 7
8. Ruben Wiki - 7
9. Ian Henderson - 7
10. Steven Price - 6
11. Simon Mannering - 6
12. Ben Matulino - 7
13. Logan Swann - 6
14. Lance Hohaia - 6
15. Sam Rapira - 6
16. Epalahame Lauaki - 6
17. Wairangi Koopu - 6
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 1
2. Misi Taulapapa - 1
3. Ben Pomeroy - 0
4. David Simmons - 1
5. Luke Covell - 1
6. Brett Seymour - 1
7. Brett Kimmorley - 1
8. Ben Ross - 1
9. Isaac De Gois - 2
10. Luke Douglas - 1
11. Paul Gallen - 0
12. Fraser Anderson - 0
15. Grant Millington - 1
14. Danny Nutley - 1
13. Greg Bird - 1
16. Adam Peek - 1
17. Terence Seu Seu - 1
 

dier

Jaws
Joined
May 16, 2008
Messages
8,066
Reaction score
172
Location
Brisbane
dier69's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 6
Got smashed but was one of the better few
2. Misi Taulapapa - 5
OUt of position several times
3. Ben Pomeroy - 5
To many drop balls
4. David Simmons - 7
The only person in our bacline not to drop a ball, also the best as well.
5. Luke Covell - 7
Good as usual, needs to be re-signed
6. Brett Seymour - 5
Pick it up buster
7. Brett Kimmorley - 6
average at best
8. Ben Ross - 7
Good
9. Isaac De Gois - 9
The only one that looked dangerous
10. Luke Douglas - 7
Good
11. Paul Gallen - 6
To many drop balls and stupid offloads
12. Fraser Anderson - 4
Worst game this year, lets hope it stops here
15. Grant Millington - 7
Good with his time on the field
14. Danny Nutley - 6
Decent, no drop balls.
13. Greg Bird - 7
Getting back to his best slowly....
16. Adam Peek - 6
Decent
17. Terence Seu Seu - 5
....
 

sharkarm

Hammerhead
Joined
Jun 12, 2007
Messages
464
Reaction score
4
Location
Gold Coast
sharkarm's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 6
2. Misi Taulapapa - 5
tries hard but still makes simple errors
3. Ben Pomeroy - 4
poor ball security
4. David Simmons - 6
5. Luke Covell - 7
good finisher
6. Brett Seymour - 3
needs to lift
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
8. Ben Ross - 7
playing well atm
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Paul Gallen - 5
12. Fraser Anderson - 5
15. Grant Millington - 6
needs more game time
14. Danny Nutley - 6
13. Greg Bird - 7
on the way back
16. Adam Peek - 6
17. Terence Seu Seu - 5
not making an impact
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 3
Is a bench player at best, need someone solid at the back.
2. Misi Taulapapa - 3
3. Ben Pomeroy - 0
Try superglue on the hands next week goose.
4. David Simmons - 3
Too slow, not first grade material
5. Luke Covell - 4
6. Brett Seymour - 0
Another below par performance.
7. Brett Kimmorley - 5
tried hard, had no support, and was always looking out for Steve Price.
8. Ben Ross - 5
Had a go.
9. Isaac De Gois - 6
Best on field (for us)
10. Luke Douglas - 5
Solid.
11. Paul Gallen - 4
If you try too hard, you look crap. He tried too hard.
12. Fraser Anderson - 2
15. Grant Millington - 2
14. Danny Nutley - 2
13. Greg Bird - 2
What happened to the Greg Bord we all know and love?
16. Adam Peek - 3
17. Terence Seu Seu - 0
VB Cup is calling...
 

sharkboy18

Great White
Joined
Jun 8, 2007
Messages
4,955
Reaction score
168
Location
Alstonville
sharkboy15's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 6
2. Misi Taulapapa - 5
3. Ben Pomeroy - 5
4. David Simmons - 6
5. Luke Covell - 7
one of the best on there, hope he secures a future with us
6. Brett Seymour - 5
7. Brett Kimmorley - 6
8. Ben Ross - 6
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
was one of the better ones, always looked dangerous
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Paul Gallen - 6
worst game all season
12. Fraser Anderson - No rating
" "
15. Grant Millington - 6
definately needs more game time
14. Danny Nutley - 6
13. Greg Bird - 7
on his way back
16. Adam Peek - 8
nearly barged over
17. Terence Seu Seu - 5
needs more attacking flair
 

pandapat

Sig Pic Geek
Joined
Sep 17, 2006
Messages
2,210
Reaction score
41
Location
Woolooware
pandapat's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 7
2. Misi Taulapapa - 6
3. Ben Pomeroy - 2
4. David Simmons - 4
5. Luke Covell - 7
6. Brett Seymour - 5
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
8. Ben Ross - 7
9. Isaac De Gois - 9
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Paul Gallen - 7
12. Fraser Anderson - 0
15. Grant Millington - 4
14. Danny Nutley - 5
13. Greg Bird - 7
16. Adam Peek - 7
17. Terence Seu Seu - 5

WARRIORS:
1. Wade McKinnon - 0
2. Malo Solomona - 0
3. Brent Tate - 0
4. Jerome Ropati - 0
5. Manu Vatuvei - 0
7. Nathan Fien - 0
8. Ruben Wiki - 0
9. Ian Henderson - 0
10. Steven Price - 0
11. Simon Mannering - 0
12. Ben Matulino - 0
13. Logan Swann - 0
14. Lance Hohaia - 0
15. Sam Rapira - 0
16. Epalahame Lauaki - 0
17. Wairangi Koopu - 0
 

sharks195

Jaws
Joined
Jul 4, 2006
Messages
6,540
Reaction score
46
Location
Ellas
sharks195's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 8
2. Misi Taulapapa - 4
3. Ben Pomeroy - 3
4. David Simmons - 7
5. Luke Covell - 5
6. Brett Seymour - 5
7. Brett Kimmorley - 5
8. Ben Ross - 8
9. Isaac De Gois - 9
10. Luke Douglas - 9
11. Paul Gallen - 7
12. Fraser Anderson - 4
15. Grant Millington - 7
14. Danny Nutley - 6
13. Greg Bird - 7
16. Adam Peek - 7
17. Terence Seu Seu - 3

WARRIORS:
1. Wade McKinnon - 7
2. Malo Solomona - 4
3. Brent Tate - 8
4. Jerome Ropati - 6
5. Manu Vatuvei - 7
6. Michael Witt - 7
7. Nathan Fien - 8
8. Ruben Wiki - 7
9. Ian Henderson - 7
10. Steven Price - 7
11. Simon Mannering - 7
12. Ben Matulino - 4
13. Logan Swann - 5
14. Lance Hohaia - 8
15. Sam Rapira - 5
16. Epalahame Lauaki - 6
17. Wairangi Koopu - 7
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 6
was good when on the field
2. Misi Taulapapa - 5
defensively a bit poor
3. Ben Pomeroy - 5
average dropped way too many balls
4. David Simmons - 6
good game, except let ropati in to score
5. Luke Covell - 7
great needs to be resigned
6. Brett Seymour - 5
in a form slump needs more early ball
7. Brett Kimmorley - 5
kicking was good
8. Ben Ross - 5
solid up front
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
great only one who looked like doing sometihng
10. Luke Douglas - 5
not alot of game time
11. Paul Gallen - 6
too many handling errors needs to stop throwing stupid offloads
12. Fraser Anderson - 4
TERRIBLE
15. Grant Millington - 5
hardly any game time
14. Danny Nutley - 6
most consistent forward
13. Greg Bird - 7
slowly back too good form needs to get more ball
16. Adam Peek - 5
nearly had a TRY
17. Terence Seu Seu - 4
little game time
 

shrek69

Bronze Whaler
Joined
Apr 7, 2007
Messages
100
Reaction score
3
Location
Central Coast N.S.W
shrek69's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 6
Looks a threat but is too light and is getting picked up and smashed in every tackle now.
2. Misi Taulapapa - 4
Back to last seasons form. This is why he shouldn't be resigned.
3. Ben Pomeroy - 4
Worst game of his career at the Sharks.
4. David Simmons - 6
Did nothing wrong but did nothing either.
5. Luke Covell - 7
played well
6. Brett Seymour - 5
Did nothing
7. Brett Kimmorley - 5
Had a shocker
8. Ben Ross - 7
Is playing well ATM
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
Our Best player by a mile. I can't believe we didn't resign him. Whoever was handle his contract neg should be sacked!!
10. Luke Douglas - 6
Quiet game
11. Paul Gallen - 6
Tried really hard but too many stupid offloads and dropped balls wrecked his performance
12. Fraser Anderson - 4
Shocker!!
15. Grant Millington - 5
Not a first grader!
14. Danny Nutley - 6
Tries hard but doesn't have enough impact anymore. Love him though!
13. Greg Bird - 5
Where was he??
16. Adam Peek - 6
NTB
17. Terence Seu Seu - 5
Did nothing, but wasn't on for long
 

imasharkie

Hammerhead
Joined
Sep 7, 2005
Messages
428
Reaction score
0
Location
Brisbane
imasharkie's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 5
he's not the player he was. no confidence, won't catch the high ball, gets bashed every time he takes the ball back. i'm not a brown fan but i'm sure he would be a better proposition for the rest of the season.
2. Misi Taulapapa - 5
shocker. happy to see him leaving.
3. Ben Pomeroy - 6
good game in defence and attack.
4. David Simmons - 6
except for a defensive lap he was good.
5. Luke Covell - 6
keep going Cov and hopefully he'll be staying for another year.
6. Brett Seymour - 6
defended strongly and his kicking was good.
7. Brett Kimmorley - 6
good in his kick chasers and although he missed a couple of tackles he defended well but his close to the line kicking was average and his attack was also average.
8. Ben Ross - 7
best game I've seen from the big man.
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
outstanding game.
10. Luke Douglas - 6
took the ball up hard and tackled strongly except for the Vatavai try.
11. Paul Gallen - 6
dropped too much ball and committed some silly errors. wet weather is not Gals game, he needs it dry.
12. Fraser Anderson - 5
had one of his worst games for us with dropped ball and missed tackles.
15. Grant Millington - 6
didn't get a lot of time and should have as he was one of our best forwards.
14. Danny Nutley - 5
played ok
13. Greg Bird - 6
still getting his fitness back.
16. Adam Peek - 6
great subby.
17. Terence Seu Seu - 4
very poor game.

WARRIORS:
1. Wade McKinnon - 5
should get suspended for his high hit.
2. Malo Solomona - 5
3. Brent Tate - 5
4. Jerome Ropati - 5
5. Manu Vatuvei - 6
6. Michael Witt - 6
7. Nathan Fien - 5
8. Ruben Wiki - 4
9. Ian Henderson - 5
10. Steven Price - 4
hope the judiciary look into his charge down attempt that has injurred Noddy
11. Simon Mannering - 6
12. Ben Matulino - 6
13. Logan Swann - 5
14. Lance Hohaia - 5
15. Sam Rapira - 5
16. Epalahame Lauaki - 5
17. Wairangi Koopu - 4
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 6
2. Misi Taulapapa - 3
3. Ben Pomeroy - 5
4. David Simmons - 3
5. Luke Covell - 5
6. Brett Seymour - 5
7. Brett Kimmorley - 5
8. Ben Ross - 5
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
10. Luke Douglas - 5
11. Paul Gallen - 5
12. Fraser Anderson - 0
15. Grant Millington - 5
14. Danny Nutley - 3
13. Greg Bird - 5
16. Adam Peek - 5
17. Terence Seu Seu - 2

WARRIORS:
1. Wade McKinnon - 5
2. Malo Solomona - 5
3. Brent Tate - 6
4. Jerome Ropati - 6
5. Manu Vatuvei - 5
6. Michael Witt - 5
7. Nathan Fien - 5
8. Ruben Wiki - 6
9. Ian Henderson - 5
10. Steven Price - 7
11. Simon Mannering - 5
12. Ben Matulino - 5
13. Logan Swann - 5
14. Lance Hohaia - 5
15. Sam Rapira - 5
16. Epalahame Lauaki - 5
17. Wairangi Koopu - 5
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs Warriors (NRL Premiership, Round 23, 2008

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 4
OK game from kearney yet is not playin with any confidence
2. Misi Taulapapa - 3
poor game from a top player in misi. will hopefully fire next week
3. Ben Pomeroy - 2
very poor game from pomz. but this is pomz and knowing him he can bounce bak quickly
4. David Simmons - 6
effective game from simmons. knows his game well and backed up well in kearney absence
5. Luke Covell - 5
good game from cov, yet needs to take the points when gifted
6. Brett Seymour - 4
bad game from buster but a player like always gets back into form
7. Brett Kimmorley - 6
i like the way he plays yet he just needs to cut some mistakes out
8. Ben Ross - 7
dangerous foward. a power machine in all angles and really earning his money.
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
best player on the field. his precense is very exciting yet unfortunately we are letting him go
10. Luke Douglas - 5
quiet game from dougy
11. Paul Gallen - 4
good running yet needs to cut out the silly errors
12. Fraser Anderson - 1
good running but come on, at nrl level you cant play like that
15. Grant Millington - 5
good with his time on the field
14. Danny Nutley - 4
good running from the nuts
13. Greg Bird - 6
his time will come. is starting to play with confidence and getting it back
16. Adam Peek - 6
stong presence and almost scored a fantastic try
17. Terence Seu Seu - 3
fine dummy half running but needs to get more time to get a higher vote
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top