Cronulla vs St George Illawarra, NRL Premiership, Round 21, 2008

[SF]

This is the ratings thread for the match:

Cronulla 13 - St George Illawarra 12
NRL Premiership, Round 21, 2008
Toyota Park, 5:30 pm, Saturday August 2, 2008

To add your ratings and/or comments, please
fill out the form on the match review page.

• Filling in the above form allows the average ratings to be automatically calculated, and your comments added to this thread (you can't post in this thread directly).
• Please login before voting if you want to have your votes recorded under your username.
• Ratings are open for a period of two weeks after the match.
• Only one vote per IP address/username is allowed.
• Ratings and comments are optional for all players. You can rate as many or as few as you would like. However, you can't go back and add/edit ratings after you vote.
• The ratings results for this match are also available on the match review page once you have voted (or skipped voting).
• The ratings leaderboard for this season is available here.
• The all-time ratings results for this grade/competition are available here.

 

[zakspiders]

zakspiders' ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 21, 2

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 7
2. Misi Taulapapa - 6
3. Ben Pomeroy - 5
4. David Simmons - 6
5. Luke Covell - 6
6. Brett Seymour - 6
7. Brett Kimmorley - 8
8. Ben Ross - 7
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
10. Luke Douglas - 8
11. Paul Gallen - 8
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
18. Grant Millington - 7
14. Danny Nutley - 6
15. Kade Snowden - 7
16. Adam Peek - 6
13. Greg Bird - 6

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
4. Matt Cooper - 8
showed why he was more valuable than gaz.one player i wished we'd bought
6. Jamie Soward - 8
never gives up

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Rou

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 6
2. Misi Taulapapa - 5
3. Ben Pomeroy - 4
4. David Simmons - 5
5. Luke Covell - 5
6. Brett Seymour - 5
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
8. Ben Ross - 7
9. Isaac De Gois - 7
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Paul Gallen - 8
12. Fraser Anderson - 6
18. Grant Millington - 5
14. Danny Nutley - 4
15. Kade Snowden - 6
16. Adam Peek - 6
13. Greg Bird - 4

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
1. Brett Morris - 5
2. Jason Nightingale - 7
3. Chase Stanley - 3
4. Matt Cooper - 8
5. Josh Morris - 6
6. Jamie Soward - 8
7. Ben Hornby - 5
8. Justin Poore - 6
9. Dean Young - 4
15. Dan Hunt - 3
11. Beau Scott - 6
12. Jarrod Saffy - 4
13. Stuart Webb - 6
Matt Prior - 5
Lagi Setu - 7
Simon Woolford - 5
Ricky Thorby - 7

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Rou

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 7
awsome
2. Misi Taulapapa - 6
pritty quiet
3. Ben Pomeroy - 6
is under acheiving
4. David Simmons - 5
had some chances and didn't back himself at all
5. Luke Covell - 6
wtf is with his goal kicking, if he converts the first try we will by 3 and is less stressful
6. Brett Seymour - 6
doesn't get enough ball lately
7. Brett Kimmorley - 8
solid game, is always the first one to get to his kick. and one us the game
8. Ben Ross - 8
solid again
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
great runs from hooker
10. Luke Douglas - 8
solid again and is going great
11. Paul Gallen - 7
over rides the play so much! every time he is on the short side the ball goes there and it f888s our little attack up!
12. Fraser Anderson - 6
played alright, nothing special, i wish he will go to the centres and have millington start every week
18. Grant Millington - 8
played great for what little time he had, he has alot of potential
14. Danny Nutley - 4
i dont know why he is in the side, honestly last night was the first time in his career he didn't drop the ball
15. Kade Snowden - 6
been good for us all year
16. Adam Peek - 6
didn't see enough of him
13. Greg Bird - 7
pritty good for a first game back

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Rou

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 8
solid as usual
2. Misi Taulapapa - 6
3. Ben Pomeroy - 6
4. David Simmons - 5
5. Luke Covell - 6
6. Brett Seymour - 6
7. Brett Kimmorley - 9
fantastic hes why where 4th
8. Ben Ross - 8
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Paul Gallen - 8
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
18. Grant Millington - 7
looked very dangerous with the ball
14. Danny Nutley - 6
15. Kade Snowden - 6
16. Adam Peek - 6
13. Greg Bird - 7

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
1. Brett Morris - 5
2. Jason Nightingale - 6
3. Chase Stanley - 5
4. Matt Cooper - 8
5. Josh Morris - 7
6. Jamie Soward - 8
7. Ben Hornby - 6
8. Justin Poore - 6
9. Dean Young - 6
15. Dan Hunt - 5
11. Beau Scott - 4
12. Jarrod Saffy - 5
13. Stuart Webb - 6
Matt Prior - 4
Lagi Setu - 7
Simon Woolford - 5
Ricky Thorby - 5

 

[Wibble]

Wibble's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 21, 2008

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 8
Fantasic game in attack and defense. One of the few Sharks to look dagerous most of the time. Some of his kick returns gave us real momentum.
2. Misi Taulapapa - 6
Looked reasonable with the few opportunities he had.
3. Ben Pomeroy - 6
Mixed game. Made many metres and was involved in a lot of half breaks. Also butchered a try and was stood up terribly to concede a try.
4. David Simmons - 7
Fairly typical solid game from Simmons, without doing anything excepional.
5. Luke Covell - 7
Took a great take to diffuse a bomb at a critical time, scored a try. Let himself down with a poor missed goal that luckily din't cost us the game.
6. Brett Seymour - 7
Fantastic toughness in defense and set up a try with a nice flick pass behind the back. Not as good a short kicking game as we would want, and his inside passes were well read by Dagons.
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
Great kick chase, as always, but short kicking was mixed. Made some line breaks running at the line.
8. Ben Ross - 7
Aother strong performance from Ross, with very powerful runs.
9. Isaac De Gois - 7
Was handled well by Dragons defense most of the evening, but made a crucial break to give field position for the winning field goal.
10. Luke Douglas - 8
Super prop's game, and helped set up the match equalling try with a kick.
11. Paul Gallen - 9
Made many crucial metres, particularly before the crucial De Gois break. Also had his usual truckload of tackles, all of them brutal, and offloads.
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
Threatened running wide of the ruck, but didn't turn that threat into anything concrete. Tackled solidy.
18. Grant Millington - 7
Shows great potetial, with some big tackles in him.
14. Danny Nutley - 7
His game may be one dimensional, but it was a dimension (forward) that helped in the second half to keep the Sharks in the Dragons half.
15. Kade Snowden - 7
Still playing tough, sometimes too tough for his own good. Combines well with the backline for a big man.
16. Adam Peek - 6
Was quite consistent, though unspectacular, coming off the bench.
13. Greg Bird - 7
Dragged in a lot of dfenders when he ran at the line, but didn't turn that into anything dangerous. Pressured the Dragons kickers into errors. A fine return from injury.

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
1. Brett Morris - 5
Played very well for the first 30 minutes until injured. The Dragons missed him.
2. Jason Nightingale - 7
Made some great runs 1st and 2nd hit up off kick returns. Was kept under control in the air.
3. Chase Stanley - 7
Good defense on the line. Was quiet in attack, as were most the backs.
4. Matt Cooper - 8
Ran very strongly, showed great footwork and speed. A usual, showed his defensive qualities that stamp him as one of the best deenders in the game.
5. Josh Morris - 8
Played well as a centre on either side of the ruck. Was the most penetrative outside back in the game.
6. Jamie Soward - 9
Superb game, tackling much bigger players to save tries, diffusing bombs, and kicking to open space. Was a menace all night.
7. Ben Hornby - 7
Solid without being brilliant.
8. Justin Poore - 7
Was very aggressive. One of the best until he was injured.
9. Dean Young - 7
A workman like game, but the Dragons probably want more from Young with Ryles and Creagh out.
15. Dan Hunt - 7
When big hit ups were needed, he put his hand up, but was mostly lacking the impact to trouble the Sharks defense.
11. Beau Scott - 7
Played with a lot of niggle against his former club, and was penalised a few times and lucky not to be binned. Also had his usual crucial error. But apart from that he ran very well and was punishing in defense.
12. Jarrod Saffy - 7
Quieter than a lot of other forwards but the plays he made were solid.
13. Stuart Webb - 7
Often put the Sharks halves under pressure with his defense. Played as a harasser and dummy half runner rather than a creative link man.
Matt Prior - 6
For a new kid in a big pressure match, he looked to have potential.
Lagi Setu - 7
Should be starting, he has the strength and footwork to be very dangerous.
Simon Woolford - 6
Was a routine effor when called in off the bench.
Ricky Thorby - 6
Should continue to develop into a good player.

 

[scott17]

scott16's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 21, 200

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 8
a great game from a great player. simple as that
2. Misi Taulapapa - 3
hopeless
3. Ben Pomeroy - 5
game to forget. he had plenty or opportunities too
4. David Simmons - 6
solid game from him considering he gets about 3 passes to him the whole game
5. Luke Covell - 7
didnt do much wron gapart from miss that kick
6. Brett Seymour - 8
great game from buster, that ball to kearney for our dis-allowed try was great so was the ball for covells try
7. Brett Kimmorley - 8
gret field goal and try, did do some dumb things but other than that he played well.
8. Ben Ross - 7
tackled hard and ran hard, not much more you could ask from him
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
gret game from de gois including those runs from dunny half which lead to our field goal
10. Luke Douglas - 7
tackles tackles and tackles, never stops working
11. Paul Gallen - 8
ran hard, tackled hard, didnt get put on report which is a bonus. played well with his partenr in crime.
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
this bloke is a talent, quiet last night by his standards but still a solid game
18. Grant Millington - 6
did well whilst he was on, a real player for the future
14. Danny Nutley - 5
didnt play much
but he took the ball foward
15. Kade Snowden - 7
a real big kid with a real big future. hard to tackle. a good prospect
16. Adam Peek - 5
didnt get to do much due to lack of game time
but he is a solid under-rated player
13. Greg Bird - 7
great to have him back

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
1. Brett Morris - 3
unlucky champ

 

[Shark68]

Shark68's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 21, 200

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 6
2. Misi Taulapapa - 5
3. Ben Pomeroy - 6
4. David Simmons - 6
5. Luke Covell - 6
6. Brett Seymour - 7
7. Brett Kimmorley - 8
8. Ben Ross - 7
9. Isaac De Gois - 7
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Paul Gallen - 8
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
18. Grant Millington - 7
14. Danny Nutley - 6
15. Kade Snowden - 6
16. Adam Peek - 6
13. Greg Bird - 6

 

[imasharkie]

imasharkie's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 21,

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 4
not performing so well atm. He gets smashed when bringing the ball back.
2. Misi Taulapapa - 5
average
3. Ben Pomeroy - 3
too big,too slow and too much of a ball hog. his defence is average. we need speed in our backline and not big lumps. was over the line and decided he would try to bump Soward off and got held up.
4. David Simmons - 6
good game from Dave. he has found some nerve in his attacking game at last.
5. Luke Covell - 6
had a lot better game this week.
6. Brett Seymour - 6
is our only attacking weapon. beautiful flick pass for Covells try and his defence is awesome.
7. Brett Kimmorley - 5
oh no he's gone back to his aweful game he has played for the last 6 years.the forwards are getting smashed every time he does his telegraphed inside ball. his kicking is a disgrace. the only thing he's got going for him is his defence.
8. Ben Ross - 6
went well. Defended well but not enough grunt in most of his runs.
9. Isaac De Gois - 5
what was he doing out there from dummy half, he looked lost.
10. Luke Douglas - 7
great game from Dougy
11. Paul Gallen - 8
our best on field. he smashes them in attack and defence.
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
the tackling machine.
18. Grant Millington - 7
Grant is looking the goods. he can be in our 17 every week if he plays like he has been lately.
14. Danny Nutley - 5
was only average. I thought he might have been injurred in the first tackle he made.
15. Kade Snowden - 6
He runs the ball powerfully and tackles with vigour. Getting more game time and deserves it
16. Adam Peek - 6
continuelly takes the ball up and tackles anyone that comes near him.
13. Greg Bird - 6
was quiet most of the time he was on the field. obviously feeling his way back and hopefully it won't be long before he starts standing out.we need him at his best.

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
1. Brett Morris - 5
2. Jason Nightingale - 5
3. Chase Stanley - 5
4. Matt Cooper - 6
5. Josh Morris - 6
6. Jamie Soward - 8
7. Ben Hornby - 6
8. Justin Poore - 8
9. Dean Young - 6
15. Dan Hunt - 5
11. Beau Scott - 4
12. Jarrod Saffy - 5
13. Stuart Webb - 5
Matt Prior - 3
Lagi Setu - 5
Simon Woolford - 5
Ricky Thorby - 5

 

[sharks195]

sharks195's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 21, 2

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 7
2. Misi Taulapapa - 6
3. Ben Pomeroy - 7
4. David Simmons - 7
5. Luke Covell - 7
6. Brett Seymour - 8
7. Brett Kimmorley - 10
8. Ben Ross - 8
9. Isaac De Gois - 9
10. Luke Douglas - 10
11. Paul Gallen - 9
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
18. Grant Millington - 7
14. Danny Nutley - 7
15. Kade Snowden - 8
16. Adam Peek - 8
13. Greg Bird - 8

ST GEORGE ILLAWARRA:
1. Brett Morris - 5
2. Jason Nightingale - 6
3. Chase Stanley - 6
4. Matt Cooper - 6
5. Josh Morris - 7
6. Jamie Soward - 8
7. Ben Hornby - 8
8. Justin Poore - 7
9. Dean Young - 6
15. Dan Hunt - 6
11. Beau Scott - 5
12. Jarrod Saffy - 5
13. Stuart Webb - 3
Matt Prior - 3
Lagi Setu - 7
Simon Woolford - 8
Ricky Thorby - 5

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Rou

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 9
2. Misi Taulapapa - 6
3. Ben Pomeroy - 6
4. David Simmons - 7
5. Luke Covell - 8
6. Brett Seymour - 8
7. Brett Kimmorley - 9
8. Ben Ross - 8
9. Isaac De Gois - 9
10. Luke Douglas - 9
11. Paul Gallen - 9
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
18. Grant Millington - 8
14. Danny Nutley - 6
15. Kade Snowden - 6
16. Adam Peek - 6
13. Greg Bird - 6

 

[sharkiesfreak]

sharkiesfreak's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 2

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 9
2. Misi Taulapapa - 7
3. Ben Pomeroy - 7
4. David Simmons - 8
5. Luke Covell - 7
6. Brett Seymour - 6
7. Brett Kimmorley - 10
8. Ben Ross - 7
9. Isaac De Gois - 10
10. Luke Douglas - 10
11. Paul Gallen - 8
12. Fraser Anderson - 8
18. Grant Millington - 7
14. Danny Nutley - 7
15. Kade Snowden - 7
16. Adam Peek - 7
13. Greg Bird - 8

 

[Pomeroy#3]

Pomeroy#3's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 21, 2

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 7
2. Misi Taulapapa - 5
3. Ben Pomeroy - 5
4. David Simmons - 7
5. Luke Covell - 6
6. Brett Seymour - 6
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
8. Ben Ross - 7
9. Isaac De Gois - 7
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Paul Gallen - 7
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
18. Grant Millington - 6
14. Danny Nutley - 5
15. Kade Snowden - 7
16. Adam Peek - 6
13. Greg Bird - 5

 

[andyshark]

andyshark's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 21, 2

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 7
massive heart, and starting to show the skills we know he has
2. Misi Taulapapa - 4
very quiet, will struggle to hold a spot in semi's on that performance
3. Ben Pomeroy - 5
no where near his best defense was off, and must look for the pass
4. David Simmons - 6
solid. starting to show somthing, would be better on misi's wing, with fraser in centre and millington staring
5. Luke Covell - 6
solid, lucky `for us all that miss didn't cost us the game
6. Brett Seymour - 7
flick pass of greatness, defense is huge lately,if he can just work on that short kicking game
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
great in the last 20mins
8. Ben Ross - 8
great game imo
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
goes hard all day, huge loss next year
10. Luke Douglas - 9
how is he not in top 46 oz team ?
11. Paul Gallen - 9
no penalty's given away, fantastic captains knock, huge heart
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
solid night, think he is a better centre though
18. Grant Millington - 7
really coming along well, maybe full time roll with gallan and bird in back row
14. Danny Nutley - 4
trys hard, but no impact these days
15. Kade Snowden - 8
very good game, going from strength to strength
16. Adam Peek - 6
didn't show much
13. Greg Bird - 7
good hit out, will be a force in finals

 

[sharkarm]

sharkarm's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Round 21, 20

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 7
solid
2. Misi Taulapapa - 7
3. Ben Pomeroy - 6
4. David Simmons - 7
5. Luke Covell - 6
6. Brett Seymour - 6
7. Brett Kimmorley - 9
man of the match
8. Ben Ross - 7
9. Isaac De Gois - 6
10. Luke Douglas - 8
workhorse
11. Paul Gallen - 8
12. Fraser Anderson - 8
18. Grant Millington - 7
14. Danny Nutley - 7
15. Kade Snowden - 7
16. Adam Peek - 5
13. Greg Bird - 6

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs St George Illawarra (NRL Premiership, Rou

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 8
fantastic
2. Misi Taulapapa - 6
alright
3. Ben Pomeroy - 6
bombed a few tries
4. David Simmons - 6
pretty quiet
5. Luke Covell - 7
solid as usual missed a goal
6. Brett Seymour - 7
good running game
7. Brett Kimmorley - 8
reason why we won
8. Ben Ross - 8
good strong carries
9. Isaac De Gois - 7
great out of dummy half
10. Luke Douglas - 7
good as usual
11. Paul Gallen - 8
played alright
12. Fraser Anderson - 6
okay
18. Grant Millington - 5
looked good with limited opputunities
14. Danny Nutley - 5
abit quiet
15. Kade Snowden - 6
good metres
16. Adam Peek - 6
pretty quiet
13. Greg Bird - 6
good return for thr sharks