Cronulla vs Souths, NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008

[SF]

This is the ratings thread for the match:

Cronulla 28 - Souths 14
NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008
Toyota Park, 7:30 pm, Saturday August 9, 2008

To add your ratings and/or comments, please
fill out the form on the match review page.

• Filling in the above form allows the average ratings to be automatically calculated, and your comments added to this thread (you can't post in this thread directly).
• Please login before voting if you want to have your votes recorded under your username.
• Ratings are open for a period of two weeks after the match.
• Only one vote per IP address/username is allowed.
• Ratings and comments are optional for all players. You can rate as many or as few as you would like. However, you can't go back and add/edit ratings after you vote.
• The ratings results for this match are also available on the match review page once you have voted (or skipped voting).
• The ratings leaderboard for this season is available here.
• The all-time ratings results for this grade/competition are available here.

 

[zakspiders]

zakspiders' ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 9
no fear attitude.starting to hit form after his injury.
2. Misi Taulapapa - 7
never gave up and made some good ground from d-half.
3. Ben Pomeroy - 8
great to see him in full flight
4. David Simmons - 7
another good game.turned the corner?
5. Luke Covell - 7
solid
6. Brett Seymour - 9
glad we've got him next year.looks intimidating.
7. Brett Kimmorley - 8
going great guns
8. Ben Ross - 8
starting to look like he means it.
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
usual from him.in everything.
10. Luke Douglas - 8
quietly goes about his work.
11. Paul Gallen - 7
if not for errors would've been close to mom.
12. Fraser Anderson - 9
lovin his work.close to the most improved this year.
15. Grant Millington - 7
not enough time on paddock.does nothing wrong.gets involved
14. Danny Nutley - 8
best from him in a long time.great 2nd half.
13. Greg Bird - 7
still feeling his way.be ready for semi's no doubt.
great hit on no.20. i hope the morris boy wasn't watching-he'll need counseling for the memories it would've brought back.
16. Adam Peek - 7
dependable as usual.needs more game time.
17. Terence Seu Seu - 7
was good when he was on.

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 9
solid at the back did everything right
2. Misi Taulapapa - 7
was really good out of dummy half
3. Ben Pomeroy - 8
should play like that every game
4. David Simmons - 7
played really well read souths attack perfectly
5. Luke Covell - 7
great as usual ran the ball more than usual
6. Brett Seymour - 9
fantastic took the line, defence great
7. Brett Kimmorley - 9
played very well sat back and let seymour do his thing
8. Ben Ross - 8
great runs reallly getting throught that first line
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
was everywhere great out of dummy half
10. Luke Douglas - 7
limited time on the field was good
11. Paul Gallen - 8
great as usual but needs to stop throwing stupid offloads
12. Fraser Anderson - 8
had a great game ran the ball well and defended great
15. Grant Millington - 7
limited oppurtunities think hes going to be good backrower
14. Danny Nutley - 8
one of his best games broke the line a few times
13. Greg Bird - 7
okay game just easing his way back had some good touches
16. Adam Peek - 6
good when he came on
17. Terence Seu Seu - 7
great out of dummy half

 

[Capmar]

Capmar's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 7
Still getting his timing but effort eas great
2. Misi Taulapapa - 5
Too many mistakes, not safe in the air & inconsistent. Great efforts but must be on the virge of losing his place
3. Ben Pomeroy - 7
Great effort and showed a return to form. Some defence lapses but otherwise a good game.
4. David Simmons - 7
Best game for a while. Solid defensively but attack is lacklustre.
5. Luke Covell - 6
Not his best game but still contributed positively.
6. Brett Seymour - 8
Rushes up too much in defence. One of the Sharks greatest improvers. Excellent game.
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
Consistent throughout with great defence. Attack however was not at its best
8. Ben Ross - 8
Staring to be an enforcer once again
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
Great defence and attack
10. Luke Douglas - 8
Good quality effort
11. Paul Gallen - 8
Fantastic game however timing of passes not always there
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
Most improved for the Sharks this year. Solid game but he would be disappointed he didnt but the line more often and stop Kidwell on 1st try
15. Grant Millington - 6
Solid. Learning his trade without mistakes. Needs to penetrate a bit more when running
14. Danny Nutley - 9
What a game. Continually buts the line and if we had a Tery Lamb support player in the team the Sharks would have scored 50+. Great game.
13. Greg Bird - 7
Still finding his fitness and timing but finding it fast. Solid in defence but timing in attack is still coming together
16. Adam Peek - 6
Solid and no no nonsense
17. Terence Seu Seu - 8
His best game for a while. Great defencive shots and ripped them apart from dummy half

 

[sharks195]

sharks195's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 8
2. Misi Taulapapa - 7
3. Ben Pomeroy - 9
4. David Simmons - 10
5. Luke Covell - 9
6. Brett Seymour - 10
7. Brett Kimmorley - 9
8. Ben Ross - 9
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
10. Luke Douglas - 9
11. Paul Gallen - 9
12. Fraser Anderson - 8
15. Grant Millington - 8
14. Danny Nutley - 10
13. Greg Bird - 9
16. Adam Peek - 9
17. Terence Seu Seu - 9

SOUTHS:
1. Nathan Merritt - 8
2. Luke Capewell - 5
3. Fetuli Talanoa - 4
4. Beau Champion - 5
5. Jamie Simpson - 3
6. Craig Wing - 6
7. Chris Sandow - 6
8. Scott Geddes - 4
9. Issac Luke - 5
10. Roy Asotasi - 7
11. Luke Stuart - 3
12. David Faalogo - 4
13. John Sutton - 7
14. Beau Falloon - 7
15. David Kidwell - 2
17. Michael Greenfield - 8
20. Eddy Pettybourne - 2

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 7
2. Misi Taulapapa - 6
3. Ben Pomeroy - 7
4. David Simmons - 7
5. Luke Covell - 8
6. Brett Seymour - 8
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
8. Ben Ross - 7
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
10. Luke Douglas - 7
11. Paul Gallen - 6
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
15. Grant Millington - 6
14. Danny Nutley - 6
13. Greg Bird - 6
16. Adam Peek - 6
17. Terence Seu Seu - 6

 

[dier]

dier69's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 8
Good game almost back to his best
2. Misi Taulapapa - 6
Good runs from dummy half.
3. Ben Pomeroy - 8
Nice to see him get some good ball.
4. David Simmons - 8
Great under the high ball, solid in defence and solid running.
5. Luke Covell - 7
Just a normal covell game safe as anything.
6. Brett Seymour - 8
Got alot more ball and it really payed off.
7. Brett Kimmorley - 8
Played well let seymour take more control.
8. Ben Ross - 9
Really starting to find some great form.
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
Great as per usual.
10. Luke Douglas - 8
Same as above.
11. Paul Gallen - 8
A few error but A hella lot of metres and tackles...
12. Fraser Anderson - 9
Great game really ran with meaning and defence was out standing .
15. Grant Millington - 7
Limited time.
14. Danny Nutley - 8
Really played well continually broke the line to bad kearney didnt follow him around.
13. Greg Bird - 8
Still settling in from his knee.
16. Adam Peek - 7
Normal peeky.
17. Terence Seu Seu - 6
Did what he had to.

 

[sharkarm]

sharkarm's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 8
2. Misi Taulapapa - 7
100% effort
3. Ben Pomeroy - 8
4. David Simmons - 8
warming to the task at hand
5. Luke Covell - 8
6. Brett Seymour - 8
strong
7. Brett Kimmorley - 8
8. Ben Ross - 8
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
10. Luke Douglas - 8
11. Paul Gallen - 7
12. Fraser Anderson - 9
man of the match
15. Grant Millington - 7
on the up
14. Danny Nutley - 9
impressive
13. Greg Bird - 7
16. Adam Peek - 7
17. Terence Seu Seu - 7

 

[imasharkie]

imasharkie's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 5
is a great general play fb but when he brings the ball back from kicks he gets smashed every time and his confidence under the high ball is not good.
2. Misi Taulapapa - 4
hands were terrible early in the game and his inconsistency might cost us in the semis.
3. Ben Pomeroy - 6
much better game this week, must have got a reving from RS
4. David Simmons - 7
must have got the same rocket from Ricky as he played one of his better games for us.
5. Luke Covell - 6
ran the ball with more purpose this week maybe the elbow is getting stronger and his confidence has improved.
6. Brett Seymour - 7
he's our best attacking kicking game proposition but he can't get the ball off Noddy. His tackling has been awesome.
7. Brett Kimmorley - 5
he's back to overplaying his hand again and this does not look good for our finals games. he needs to share the attacking workload and give the ball to Buster every time we are bombing on the 6th as Noddy's bombing is pathetic.he's still got that problem of not finding touch from a penalty and surely we have got someone with a bigger kick than him. i rate his kicking game as 4/10
8. Ben Ross - 7
he carted the ball up with more gusto and this could be due tio him having completely recoverred from his knee op. he also defended strongly.
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
best game in ages from Isaac.
10. Luke Douglas - 7
seemed to get less time on the field which could be due to his leg problem. when he was on the field he smashed them.
11. Paul Gallen - 7
his ball control in the first half was terrible but that didn't distract too much from his all round game.
12. Fraser Anderson - 8
has been our most consistent forward this season and his tackling is awesome. good to see he is getting his running game togerther and looks certain to end up back in the centres.
15. Grant Millington - 6
didn't get a long time on the field but when he was he was quality.
14. Danny Nutley - 6
excellent game from Nuts.
13. Greg Bird - 6
i reckon he's still feeling his way back from injury and when he gets more confidence and match fitness he will be on.
16. Adam Peek - 6
great in defence and attack and is a fantastic bench player, hope he stays around next year.
17. Terence Seu Seu - 5
little time to show us what he's got.

SOUTHS:
1. Nathan Merritt - 6
2. Luke Capewell - 4
3. Fetuli Talanoa - 5
4. Beau Champion - 5
5. Jamie Simpson - 5
6. Craig Wing - 6
7. Chris Sandow - 8
dangerous.
8. Scott Geddes - 5
9. Issac Luke - 5
10. Roy Asotasi - 5
11. Luke Stuart - 6
12. David Faalogo - 6
13. John Sutton - 7
14. Beau Falloon - 5
15. David Kidwell - 5
17. Michael Greenfield - 5
20. Eddy Pettybourne - 5

 

[Unregistered]

Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 8
not confident since we played manly, but played well
2. Misi Taulapapa - 9
100% wanted to be there this week and performed
3. Ben Pomeroy - 10
great game, missed a tackle on his inside and led to a try. he needs to get this right before the finals.
4. David Simmons - 8
great under a high ball, like to see him go to the wing, and push misi out of the side.
5. Luke Covell - 10
awsome great game
6. Brett Seymour - 8
didnt see much ball
7. Brett Kimmorley - 9
solid, but kicking on the 5th to much
8. Ben Ross - 8
great game
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
we don't need terance. isaac can go the full 80 and do it well
10. Luke Douglas - 9
nothing needs to be said other than consistant
11. Paul Gallen - 7
to many droped balls and stupid penalties
12. Fraser Anderson - 8
performed. like to see fraser go to the centres.
15. Grant Millington - 9
great for a young kid and performs on the feild extremely well. like to see him go to the second row full time when fraser goes to the centre
14. Danny Nutley - 9
best game this year
13. Greg Bird - 7
not 100% fit yet, needs time
16. Adam Peek - 6
nothing special
17. Terence Seu Seu - 6
played good when on the feild

 

[pandapat]

pandapat's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 8
Great confidence, great running
2. Misi Taulapapa - 7
Dropped the ball once stupidly, nothing else wrong
3. Ben Pomeroy - 8
Solid game
4. David Simmons - 9
great improvement, backed himself, played well
5. Luke Covell - 7
Good average game
6. Brett Seymour - 8
Solid Game
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
Good kicking game
8. Ben Ross - 8
Played with heart
9. Isaac De Gois - 8
Good dummy half running
10. Luke Douglas - 7
Average game
11. Paul Gallen - 8
Strong game
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
Average
15. Grant Millington - 8
just gets better
14. Danny Nutley - 7
Good hard running
13. Greg Bird - 8
great to have him back!
16. Adam Peek - 7
Average
17. Terence Seu Seu - 7
Played alright in his time

 

[sharkiesfreak]

sharkiesfreak's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 22, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 9
2. Misi Taulapapa - 8
i thought he played alright did some good tough stuff
3. Ben Pomeroy - 10
is there anyone better at cutting back in if so i havent seen them
4. David Simmons - 10
best game from in since last year
5. Luke Covell - 9
solid but did wat he had to
6. Brett Seymour - 8
quiete but still great
7. Brett Kimmorley - 10
awesome again noddy steers the boys around well
8. Ben Ross - 8
solid a fgew penalites but u cant blame him 4 that
9. Isaac De Gois - 9
strong out of dummy half just think he could actually attempt to score a try from dummy half every now and then
10. Luke Douglas - 9
work horse as usual
11. Paul Gallen - 8
did wat he had 2 a few mistakes tho cost him
12. Fraser Anderson - 8
did wat he does best
15. Grant Millington - 7
still dont think he is cut out for 1st grade but ricky is the coach not me
14. Danny Nutley - 10
perfect game from nuts never saw him the drop the ball
13. Greg Bird - 9
still getting right but still a threat 2 everyone
16. Adam Peek - 8
the journeyman just keeps turning up every week
17. Terence Seu Seu - 7
still needs more game time i think he is a wasted sub but still a good player

SOUTHS:
1. Nathan Merritt - 0
thank god we got rid of him
2. Luke Capewell - 0
3. Fetuli Talanoa - 0
4. Beau Champion - 0
5. Jamie Simpson - 0
6. Craig Wing - 0
7. Chris Sandow - 0
8. Scott Geddes - 0
9. Issac Luke - 0
10. Roy Asotasi - 0
11. Luke Stuart - 0
12. David Faalogo - 0
13. John Sutton - 0
14. Beau Falloon - 0
15. David Kidwell - 0
17. Michael Greenfield - 0
20. Eddy Pettybourne - 0