Cronulla vs Canterbury, NRL Premiership, Round 11, 2008

[SF]

This is the ratings thread for the match:

Canterbury 30 - Cronulla 22
NRL Premiership, Round 11, 2008
, 7:00 pm, Monday May 26, 2008

To add your ratings and/or comments, please
fill out the form on the match review page.

• Filling in the above form allows the average ratings to be automatically calculated, and your comments added to this thread (you can't post in this thread directly).
• Please login before voting if you want to have your votes recorded under your username.
• Ratings are open for a period of two weeks after the match.
• Only one vote per IP address/username is allowed.
• Ratings and comments are optional for all players. You can rate as many or as few as you would like. However, you can't go back and add/edit ratings after you vote.
• The ratings results for this match are also available on the match review page once you have voted (or skipped voting).
• The ratings leaderboard for this season is available here.
• The all-time ratings results for this grade/competition are available here.

 

[bort]

bort's ratings for Cronulla vs Canterbury (NRL Premiership, Round 11, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 5
21. Mitch Brown - 4
3. Ben Pomeroy - 6
12. Fraser Anderson - 6
4. David Simmons - 5
6. Brett Seymour - 7
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
8. Adam Peek - 6
9. Isaac De Gois - 5
16. Kade Snowden - 7
10. Luke Douglas - 5
12. Paul Gallen - 6
13. Greg Bird - 6
14. Danny Nutley - 5
17. Terence Seu Seu - 5
19. Jason Bukuya - 5
20. Ben Ross - 5

CANTERBURY:
1. Cameron Phelps - 5
2. Hazem El Masri - 6
3. Daryl Millard - 5
4. Tim Winitana - 7
5. Matthew Utai - 8
6. Daniel Holdsworth - 6
7. Ben Roberts - 5
8. Jarrad Hickey - 6
9. Corey Hughes - 7
10. Chris Armit - 7
11. Sonny Bill Williams - 7
12. Andrew Ryan - 7
13. Reni Maitua - 6
14. Lee Te Maari - 5
15. Kosta Kouparitsis - 5
16. Michael Sullivan - 5
17. Brad Morrin - 5

 

[Pomeroy#3]

Pomeroy#3's ratings for Cronulla vs Canterbury (NRL Premiership, Round 11, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 6
Injured early on.
21. Mitch Brown - 5
Rusty understandably after injury.
3. Ben Pomeroy - 4
Dreadful in defence, normally a strong point of his game.
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
With limited footy, he played well and ran the footy well in attack.
4. David Simmons - 7
Offers nothing much in attack, though made some very important tackles during the match at the back.
6. Brett Seymour - 7
Played solid, had some nice touches.
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
Played solid, had some nice touches.
8. Adam Peek - 7
Solid game up front, nothing special.
9. Isaac De Gois - 7
Took a knock early on and played through it, shows his character, had some nice touches from dummy half.
16. Kade Snowden - 7
Shows glimses of promise, though looks like he lacks some match fitness. Great effort chasing down Benny Roberts from behind to save a certain try.
10. Luke Douglas - 6
So so game from Dougy, hasn't really lived up to my expectations this season so far.
12. Paul Gallen - 6
Quite game from Gals, we needed him and Bird to lead the way for us tonight when we seemed lost & down and out.
13. Greg Bird - 6
Quite game from Birdy, he knew it aswell from what I took from his interview with Andy Raymond after the match.
14. Danny Nutley - 5
Doesn't do much for me, I think Norrie should be over the Nuts.
17. Terence Seu Seu - 7
Had some nice scoots from dummy half. Looks like T and Kinga will be our next year's hooker rotation. (Kinga starting)
19. Jason Bukuya - 7
Solid debut, ecspecially out of position.
20. Ben Ross - 6
Did he play like a $400k a season player? I don't think he did. Let's hope he improves the more matches he gets under his belt.

CANTERBURY:
6. Daniel Holdsworth - 7
Best half all season from him, before he got injured and replaced.
11. Sonny Bill Williams - 8
Only threat for us.

 

[imasharkie]

imasharkie's ratings for Cronulla vs Canterbury (NRL Premiership, Round 11, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 5
didn't do a lot when he was on the field.
21. Mitch Brown - 4
terrible in both defence and attack. Bring back Goodwin.
3. Ben Pomeroy - 4
awful game. Defence non existant.
12. Fraser Anderson - 6
kept the rh defence together. Bulldogs gave up on that side in attack. Good game in offence too.
4. David Simmons - 4
Not a fullback.
6. Brett Seymour - 6
worked hard in both attack and defence.
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
Best player on the field for Cronulla. Kicking game was almost spot on.
8. Adam Peek - 5
did his job ok except when he was having a bludge in the centres on one of how attacking raids and a try would've been scored only he threw a horror pass to the winger.
9. Isaac De Gois - 6
toiled well in defence unfortunately the moment he got smashed by Utai his attacking game went to pieces.
16. Kade Snowden - 7
Had agreat game in attack and defence. Gave him an extra point for running down Roberts.
10. Luke Douglas - 5
Does a good job in defence although he is getting caught out at marker defence a bit lately. His attacking game is shot and he's not the player he was last year.
12. Paul Gallen - 6
worked really hard but did not have his usual punch in attack. Too much footy.
13. Greg Bird - 6
the same as Galls
14. Danny Nutley - 6
worked his butt off unfortunately he dropped that ball.
17. Terence Seu Seu - 5
Just wish he'd learn not to pass the ball to a player in front of him.
19. Jason Bukuya - 6
outstanding debut. What about that tackle. Wham Bam thank you for coming.
20. Ben Ross - 5
did well in his return but he better learn a bit about ball control or Sticky will give it to him again.

CANTERBURY:
1. Cameron Phelps - 7
2. Hazem El Masri - 3
3. Daryl Millard - 5
4. Tim Winitana - 6
5. Matthew Utai - 6
6. Daniel Holdsworth - 7
7. Ben Roberts - 5
8. Jarrad Hickey - 6
9. Corey Hughes - 8
10. Chris Armit - 5
11. Sonny Bill Williams - 8
12. Andrew Ryan - 8
13. Reni Maitua - 7
14. Lee Te Maari - 5
15. Kosta Kouparitsis - 5
16. Michael Sullivan - 4
17. Brad Morrin - 4

 

[dier]

dier69's ratings for Cronulla vs Canterbury (NRL Premiership, Round 11, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 6
yer injured.
21. Mitch Brown - 2
Dreadful.
3. Ben Pomeroy - 5
mitch brown didnt help much in defence but niether did Benny
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
One of the best on the field should be centre from now on wit simmons outside him
4. David Simmons - 6
good in attack half breakin the line a few times.
6. Brett Seymour - 7
Glad he is ours for the next 2 years
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
A normal noddy game
8. Adam Peek - 6
decent not great
9. Isaac De Gois - 6
Head knock didnt help
16. Kade Snowden - 6
gonna be good one day
10. Luke Douglas - 6
Yer
12. Paul Gallen - 6
Hurtin from origin?
13. Greg Bird - 6
Hurtin from origin?
14. Danny Nutley - 5
Try scorin freak!
17. Terence Seu Seu - 2
YUCK!
19. Jason Bukuya - 4
Nice hit.
20. Ben Ross - 4
400k umm no!

 

[Boundos]

Boundos' ratings for Cronulla vs Canterbury (NRL Premiership, Round 11, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 2
Injured early, god we missed him!
21. Mitch Brown - 1
Added nothing to attack, gave up a few tries with bad def reads. Bring back Misi
3. Ben Pomeroy - 3
Worst game i have seen him play all year
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
Stepped up i thought. Solid performance
4. David Simmons - 6
Filled in at the back when Kearny went. Played solid
6. Brett Seymour - 5
Not a bad performance. Great ball to put bird into a gap for ando's try
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
Played his guts out as per usual. Little on the quiet side
8. Adam Peek - 8
I thought he played well tonight. Especially as there wasnt much support for him in the forwards
9. Isaac De Gois - 7
Showed good ticker, playing solid after being knocked for 6 early
16. Kade Snowden - 8
Played a great game. Great chase down of Roberts
10. Luke Douglas - 4
Worst I have seen him play in a long time. Stupid penalties, and not much else
12. Paul Gallen - 6
Quiet game for Galls. Was backing up from SOO though
13. Greg Bird - 7
As above
14. Danny Nutley - 6
Resoanble game from Nuts. reat try.
17. Terence Seu Seu - 6
Still finding his way at hooker for the team i think. Has potential
19. Jason Bukuya - 5
Couple of mistakes, but a good debut. Would like to see him and Misi on the wings
20. Ben Ross - 6
Quiet return match.

 

[Shire Shark]

Shire Shark's ratings for Cronulla vs Canterbury (NRL Premiership, Round 11, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 5
Injured early and didnt have time to do much
21. Mitch Brown - 3
Pathetic, he acually got paid for that performance.
3. Ben Pomeroy - 5
Not at his barnstorming best
12. Fraser Anderson - 6
He is a backrower but played quite well and continues to improve
4. David Simmons - 6
best game this season. Ran with a bit of pep, and pulled off great try-saving tackle on phelps.
6. Brett Seymour - 6
seemed off tonight
7. Brett Kimmorley - 7
In a bit of a purple patch
8. Adam Peek - 8
Best prop. Always went forwed.
9. Isaac De Gois - 4
Groggy for most of game. Cant pass wich is not good considering he is a hooker.
16. Kade Snowden - 7
Good game. Great covering tackle, showing a bit of toe. I can see a big future.
10. Luke Douglas - 5
It is dissapointing seeing players lose form so quickly.
12. Paul Gallen - 5
Embarrasing game by his high standards, seemed a bit flat.
13. Greg Bird - 5
Our superstar seemsed tired, but tried
14. Danny Nutley - 4
selmes was dropped for this!
17. Terence Seu Seu - 6
Get used to premier league kingston, seu seu is here to stay
19. Jason Bukuya - 6
showed promise, but he must have taken lessons from nutley on how to catch.
20. Ben Ross - 6
good game back from suspention. More minutes and more involvment will be good for ross

 

[brad]

brad's ratings for Cronulla vs Canterbury (NRL Premiership, Round 11, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 3
21. Mitch Brown - 4
3. Ben Pomeroy - 5
12. Fraser Anderson - 6
4. David Simmons - 7
6. Brett Seymour - 7
7. Brett Kimmorley - 6
8. Adam Peek - 7
9. Isaac De Gois - 5
16. Kade Snowden - 7
10. Luke Douglas - 5
12. Paul Gallen - 5
13. Greg Bird - 5
14. Danny Nutley - 5
17. Terence Seu Seu - 4
19. Jason Bukuya - 6
20. Ben Ross - 6

 

[chikenhawk]

chikenhawk's ratings for Cronulla vs Canterbury (NRL Premiership, Round 11, 2008)

CRONULLA:
1. Brett Kearney - 5
injury definately had the sharks on the back foot.
21. Mitch Brown - 4
definately not the comeback he would have hoped for.
3. Ben Pomeroy - 6
did some good things, did some shockers as well.
12. Fraser Anderson - 7
another impressive performance
4. David Simmons - 6
i think he enjoyed his time at fullback, but made some silly decisions.
6. Brett Seymour - 8
played a great second half, he created alot of opportunities however most times didnt have support. his combination with bird is looking better each week as well.
7. Brett Kimmorley - 6
another good performance, like always his effort is there. i just think he needs to let seymour and bird do a bit more playmaking, his decisions and passes are too late. kick and chase great again.
8. Adam Peek - 6
one of the best forwards on the park. in the second half ate up some meters. all the forwards were soft inthe first half.
9. Isaac De Gois - 6
wasnt one of his best peformances, but probably due to his knock. why are we letting this guy leave?
16. Kade Snowden - 7
best forward playing tonight.
10. Luke Douglas - 5
not the greatest performance from the youngster. i think it will take him some time to get used to the second row.
12. Paul Gallen - 5
very stale from origin. he had ample time to back up from origin, that just cannot be an excuse for him or bird. the time between the two games was the same as if a team played on a sunday and then had hte friday night game the next week.
13. Greg Bird - 6
like gallen, inexcusably stale from origin. second half was much better, i love seeing him and seymour combine. probably didnt do as much as he would have liked.
14. Danny Nutley - 5
a bit below average, normally alot better ball security. great try, jeez no one was going to stop him. good to see him get the four pointer.
17. Terence Seu Seu - 4
is really struggling in the top grade. getting better though this game was not one of his best.
19. Jason Bukuya - 5
impressive debut. will only get better.
20. Ben Ross - 4
played well, but stupid things he does like his push on sbw is just f**king pathetic. also had a late hit on matt utai that wasnt noticed and ran away like a little girl. this guy needs to wake up to himself and get fired up at the right times. ran hard and good comback, however his discipline needs attention.

CANTERBURY:
1. Cameron Phelps - 6
2. Hazem El Masri - 4
3. Daryl Millard - 6
4. Tim Winitana - 6
5. Matthew Utai - 5
6. Daniel Holdsworth - 7
7. Ben Roberts - 5
8. Jarrad Hickey - 5
9. Corey Hughes - 8
10. Chris Armit - 6
11. Sonny Bill Williams - 7
12. Andrew Ryan - 8
13. Reni Maitua - 6
14. Lee Te Maari - 5
15. Kosta Kouparitsis - 2
16. Michael Sullivan - 4
17. Brad Morrin - 5