Burgo's Brainy Bench Breakdown - 2021 Round 1 (Dragons)

BurgoShark

Super Moderator
Joined
Apr 8, 2008
Messages
12,831
Reaction score
4,051
This week I broke down the performance of a couple of our bench players (Magoulias and Williams). The reaction was very positive, so I did the other two.

I'll post the breakdowns for each player in this thread.

Quick Summary:

#14 Connor Tracey played the final 9 minutes of the game

#15 Aiden Tolman played ~45 minutes, split up in to three separate stints
- 17 minutes before half time
- 22 minutes after half time
- 6 minutes at the end of the game

#16 Jack Williams played ~28 minutes
- 12 minutes before hand time
- 16 minutes after half time

#17 Billy Magoulias played ~11 minutes
 

BurgoShark

Super Moderator
Joined
Apr 8, 2008
Messages
12,831
Reaction score
4,051
#14 Connor Tracey

- 72nd minute - Tracey replaces Brailey as the Sharks kick down and tackle the Dragons on the 20
- Dragons are playing hot potato. Tracey is involved in one tackle and also gets palmed off by a big man
- Dragons score from the bomb
- Sharks kick off 90 seconds later with just under 6 minutes on the clock
- Tracey is involved in 2 tackles in the next set
- Dragons get caught on the 5th and hand it over on the 20
- Next set starts with a Ramien run. Tracey then goes in to dummy half on tackle 1 for his first touch, and takes a scoot on tackle 2
- Service out of dummy half is good through the set. Sharks kick to the corner and the Dragons drop it
- Tackle 1 Tracey goes to Chad, who goes back inside to Woods for the try. Tracey was backing up Woods on the inside. Good support play
- Dragons rush the kick off, but it doesn't go 10. Sharks kick to touch. All in all another 90 seconds between action
- Tracey to dummy half on tackle 1. Poor pass behind Chad leads to a clunky shift left
- Next play is Wade drop/challenge. Sharks continue with Tracey to dummy half
- Tracey throws a shocker out in front of Chad
- Tracey is involved in one tackle in the final 30 seconds before the game ends

So all in all Tracey was on the park for 9 minutes but lost 3 to stoppages. In his 6 minutes of action he had one run, a handful of short passes out of dummy half, and two attempted long passes that were both pretty ordinary.
 
Joined
Feb 3, 2015
Messages
8,132
Reaction score
2,404
Last time we had a 'B' alliteration thread it got taken away. I suspect this one might not have that problem.

Appreciate the effort into these posts Burgess. I enjoy the read.
 

BurgoShark

Super Moderator
Joined
Apr 8, 2008
Messages
12,831
Reaction score
4,051
#15 Aiden Tolman

- 24th minute: Tolman on for Woods after the Chad penalty goal. He takes the first run from the kick off. Knees + elbows and a good ptb. This set is nearly all forward runs
- Set ends with a kick and Dragons being tackled about 23m out. Tolman isn't involved in the tackle but he is nearby and gets to second marker
- Makes 2 tackles in a row this set, including good contact on Ravalawa and getting him on to his back
- 5th tackle he puts good kick pressure on Clune
- Next set Tolman takes a lead run on tackle 4 and then makes good yards on tackle 5. Gets wrestled onto his back late. End result is slow play the ball and Chad gets thumped as he kicks it
- Only involved in one tackle this set. Legs tackle. Gets to second marker yet again
- Again good kick pressure on Hunt this time. Doesn't quite get there in time to put him off but he would have been in his eyeline for sure
- Next Sharks set is an exit set with backs taking all of the runs. It ends with Wade putting the ball in to touch with Ramien not far away frmo returning
- Roughly 20 seconds elapses between when the ball crosses the touchline and when the ragons play it in the middle of teh field
- Tolman makes one good legs tackle early in the set, but teh Dragons are playing hot potato. A couple more times he covers across to be there if needed, and gets to second marker. On the second of those the Dragons have no dummy half and Tolman gets the pill
- Not involved in this set other than a lead run on an out-the-back play.
- Fifth tackle ends in a Ronny kick to the middle and Tolman chases though to force the repeat set
- Next set is clearly set up for specific plays. Tolman takes a lead run on a right side shift, then quickly comes back to the middle to setup for a support run inside Williams. Next play is an unders play to Tolman from the dummy half but they read it he gets flopped onto his back. Sharks end the set with a poor kick from Wade
- No involvement from Tolman in defence on the next Dragons set, but he's up quick with the line and in position. Dragons kick on the 4th so Tolman doesn't pressure the kicker this time. Kennedy drops the ball
- Tolman makes one tackle in the next set, but the bloke slips as he gets to him. The Dragons set ends with a ball going dead in goal and a Sharks 20 restart
- Tolman makes good metres on tackle 2 (with Rudolf in support). A better play the ball this time leads to a nice shift left, followed by an offload and they make 30+ metres. Next play Kennedy puts it in goal and the Sharks get another set
- Tolman takes the run from the dropout. Really good metres and he gets to his belly, but the Dragons hold on for ages. Still a quick-ish player the ball though and it leads to good metres for Williams on the next play. He takes another settler on tackle 3 before a quick shift. Again a good play the ball.
- The set ends with yet another short kick to the in goal and a repeat set
- This time Toby takes the run from the kick, and on play 2 Tolman runs a tip on for Williams. They make good metres and get a good play the ball from Williams. They go to Chad on the right who uses Tolman as an inside runner and he almost slips through. Brailey is there in support but is flat footed and not quite close enough. If he is closer or if there is an extra support runner on that play and Tolman could easily have offloaded. Instead he gets taken in a legs tackle and gets a really quick play the ball, but as they shift right it's not a great pass from Blayke and Nikora drops it
- On the next defensive set, Tolman is involved in one tackle, but the Dragons go side-line to side line so generally avoid him.
- On the fifth he comes up to pressure the kicker but is taken out by a blocker (one of my pet hates) and can't get to Hunt. Watching again now this is as obvious an obstruction penalty as I have ever seen. McCullough stands in front of Hunt and then eyeballs Tolman coming through and moves to take him out NFL blocker style.
- Sharks bring it out of their own end. Tolman takes a lead run off Nikora. Sharks get a penalty and awful field goal attempts ensue and it is half time

***

- Second half Tolman takes the opening run, gets to his belly and gets an "ok" play the ball. He backs up again on tackle 5 and gets a bet better play the ball setting up for Chad's clearing kick. He doesn't chase the kick, but that could be because he played the ball and didn't want to be pinged for downtown. He lumbers down and joins the line as the tackle is made
- 2 very good tackles on this set. First he dominates Jack Bird and gets him on his back, and then he makes a perfect legs tackle on Merrin. He's caught on the opposite side to the kicker when the set ends, so doesn't come up to pressure the kicker. Brailey and Williams do a good job of that though. Tolman walks back with the rest of the middles and re-joins the attack around tackle 2 while the wingers, centres and back rowers work it out
- On the fifth he lines up for one of those blocker plays I hate so much, but unlike McCullough he lets the Dragons chaser keep his line, and Tolman starts making his way down field as the Sharks shift right and get the kick away via Katoa. Dufty fumbles before recovering, and Tolman makes the tackle (with help). He makes one more tackle in this set before a Dragons grubber is fielded by Kennedy.
- Sharks work it away from their end again without much involvement from the forwards, though Tolman has one lead run and then a hit up on tackle 4 with a quick ptb. Ramien makes good metres from dummy half on the back of it and gets a good ptb himself for tackle 5 and the clearing kick. Tolman is in the lead chasnig group but doesn't make a tackle. Tolman makes another good tackle in this set, and gets to second marker again. Lomax throws the ball over the sideline on the next play
- Great next set for Tolman despite not getting a touch. Dummy run, lead run, dummy run, hold position, dummy run. This is the sort of play that will never show up on a stat sheet, but makes a huge difference. Sharks go 60 metres in 5 plays, kick to a corner and have the Dragons 10m out on tackle 1. Unfortunately at the end of teh set the Sharks let an innocuous bomb from 40 out bounce and teh Dragons score
- 90 seconds later, Tolman leads the chase from the kick off, makes the tackle, and then backs it up with 2 more after that, and a 4th one for the set. Vaughan goes through Williams and Brailey but Nikora gets enough of him to take him down. Tolman is right there covering and dives on Vaughan after he is on the ground.
- Dragons set ends with a bomb and Brailey diving on a bat-back and the Sharks again come out of their own end through outside backs. Tolman is in the lead chase pack for the kick but doesn't make the tackle
- The next defensive set is a bit of a debacle. On the first tackle Dufty walks about 3m off the mark and takes the first marker out of play (Billy). This leads to a quick play the ball, followed by Brailey falling off a tackle. Tolman and Moylan are required to tidy up the half break. Then Brailey on tackle gives up a set restart. It hasn't been a happy few minutes for Blayke, but he makes a good tackle on the next play and Tolman is there to help. Tolman makes another good legs tackle soon after, before Hunt brushes off William and Tolman arrives too late to stop the offload. Dufty's gets excited and puts in a terrible kick no tackle 3 though, so the Sharks aren't made to pay.
- On the turnover, Tolman takes the hard yards hit-up from his own 10, makes half a metre and gets the world's slowest play the ball because he's got a Dragon draped over him. Another play that won't get him any love from the stats column, but I guarantee the other 12 blokes out there were glad he put his hand up. Graham, Magoulias and Williams take the next 3 runs in similar fashion, all making hardly any metres and getting whacked for their trouble
- Sharks get a set restart on the Williams run for inside 10. The edges come in now and ruck it away. Tolman with another good lead run for Ramien on tackle 2 and a dummy run for Billy on a nice left side shift on play 4 that ends with Dugan having a half chance. Sharks kick to the corner and tackle the Dragons ~12m out. Tolman is in the lead chase group and is involved in the tackle
- Tackle 3 and 4 Tolman is involved in the tackle
- Tackle 4 Dufty goes straight up the guts. I've covered this plenty when talking about the other two guys. Tolman does his job here imo. He holds at second marker, tracks the play well, and has every reason to expect Williams to close the distance
- 90 seconds later, Tolman is in the lead group from the kick off and makes the tackle.
- Dragons cough it up on play 2, Tolman takes a settler in good field position and gets a slow play the ball off a surrender tackle. 2 tackles later he takes a lead run for Woods. Unfortunately Woods turns it over on tackle 5. Tolman makes one tackle on the next set before the Dragons spill it again. The game is getting a little sloppy
- Another set, another lead run and 2 more dummy runs for Tolman - and another dropped ball (this time Wade)
- Tolman makes 2 tackles in the next set, gets a rest for the the review of the Ramsey no-try, and is replaced by Toby immediately following the scrum

**

After a short rest, Tolman returns to the field after the with 5:51 remaining. As per usual, he leads the chase from the kick off and makes the tackle. He also makes a good legs tackle on McCullough on the 4th and then chases hard from marker to catch Hunt on the last for a handover
- Sharks work it away. Tolman has another lead run and this time Woods gives him the footy. Sharks kick to a corner, get the ball back, and Woods scores on the first tackle. Anyone want to guess who the outside dummy runner was before Chad turned it back inside to Woods?
- Last couple of minutes after kick off Tolman has one more dummy run, and the game is done

**

Tolman's work off the ball is fantastic. Watching him closely you really notice how quick he gets in to position for set plays, lead runs, etc. and how often he is supporting the ball runner and taking pressure off his teammates. He is certainly not fancy, but I'm very impressed by his attention to detail on these little 1% plays. He's also a very strong defender with good mix of great low-tackle technique and the ability to dominate tackles up high. If those are the sort of minutes we get out of him all year he will be worth every penny.
 

BurgoShark

Super Moderator
Joined
Apr 8, 2008
Messages
12,831
Reaction score
4,051
#16 Jack Williams

(Copied and pasted from the Williams thread)

- Comes on to the field with ~12 minutes left in the first half, and with Ramien still having around 1 minute left in the sin bin. Sharks kick it out and Ramien comes back on not long after
- Next few minutes the action stays away from him, until the Sharks get a repeat set and he finally gets a hit up from a drop out about 3 minutes later. Knees + elbows + quick ptb
- He gets a second hit up on the same set. Knees + elbows + quick ptb
- With 6 minutes to go he covers a grubber in goal and saves a try
- Next set he takes a hit up. Knees + elbows + quick ptb (are you noticing a pattern here?)
- Sharks get another repeat set
- He takes another hit up. Knees + elbows + quick ptb... but the ref calls him back for walking off the mark (fair call imo)
- and yet another hit up on the same set. Knees + elbows + quick ptb. Sharks get another repeat set
- next set... another run, another quick ptb. Nikora drops it a couple of tackles later
- last two sets, Dragons ruck it up, then kick, then the penalty and field goal shots. No runs or tackles for Williams

***

At the end of first half he has played 12 minutes, but wasn't involved at all in the first 2 or last 2. In the 8 minutes in between the Sharks had the ball almost the whole time and he ran the ball 6 times for good yards and great play the balls (including the one that was called back).

Defensively: 12 minutes for 0 tackles and 0 misses

***

- Second half the Dragons kick off. Williams takes run #2. Another strong run and a quick ptb.
- At the end of the set Townsend kicks and Williams in three tackles the next set. The tackle-less streak is over at 13 minutes
- Next set he isn't involved in attack
- Dragons next set he makes 2 tackles
- Next set he isn't involved in attack
- Makes 2 good tackles in a row on the Dragons next possession
- Next Sharks possession he takes a run and gets turtled. Slow ptb
- Next Dragons set he makes 4 tackles in a row. He's starting to walk in defence
- Next set he makes 2 tackles in row and then lets Vaughan go through him like a turnstile
- No involvement on the next Sharks set, but chases the kick and is involved in the tackle
- Next Dragons set he is walking again in defence. Dragons get a set restart. Williams has a bad miss on Hunt but Dufty knocks on soon after
- Next Sharks possession he takes a run and gets turtled. Slow ptb
- Sharks kick again and Williams is involved in the tackle
- Tackle 4 the Dragons play the ball in the middle, the A defender on the left (Brailey) moves up and left but Williams stands still. He doesn't move up and doesn't shift across to cover the space. Dufty goes straight in to the hole Williams should be standing in and makes the Sharks look silly.
- One tackle after the kick off Williams is replaced by Woods

***

So... as per pretty much every game he plays, Williams is an attacking weapon with one of the best ptb's in the comp... but when he has to do a big defensive workload he gets tired very quickly, gets targeted, and he struggles.

First 13 minutes: 6 runs, 0 tackles, 0misses
Next 9 minutes: 1 run , 13 tackles, 0 misses
Then in his final 5 minutes he has one run where he gets turtled, makes one tackle, has Vaughan go through him, has Hunt go through him, and waves at Dufty while standing still

Williams is the poster child for the new rules. Big guy + fatigue = points.
 

BurgoShark

Super Moderator
Joined
Apr 8, 2008
Messages
12,831
Reaction score
4,051
#17 Billy Magoulias

(Copied and pasted from the Magoulias thread)

- Comes on to the field in the 46th minute
- First set he leads the kick chase but someone else makes the tackle, he gets to marker a few times during the set and makes a couple of good tackles
- Dragons score of a bomb, and about 90 seconds elapses between the try and the next kick off
- Next set he leads the chase from the kick off and makes 2 more good tackles
- 50th minute Brailey dives on a loose ball and the Sharks get the ball for the first time in Billy's stint. They run an exit set towards the left edge (i.e. away from where the lock is) and kick it
- Billy leads the kick chase and is involved in the tackle
- Brailey gives up a set restart on 3rd tackle
- Billy makes a good tackle on the next set
- Dragons then turn it over on the Sharks 10
- Billy takes a hit up on tackle 2
- Sharks get a set restart on tackle 3
- On the 3rd tackle Billy is involved in a shift to the left. Makes a crisp, clean pass to Townsend. Shift leads to a half break. Sharks then bomb to a corner and tackle the Dragons about 12m out
- Billy leads the kick chase but someone else makes the tackle. Billy makes 3 tackles in a row in this set
- Billy chases from marker, Dragons go back through the middle to find a lazy A defender in Williams and score on the 4th tackle. Another 90 seconds elapses between the try and the kick-off
- Billy leads the kick chase again from the kick off and makes the tackle. Dragons drop it on the second tackle.
- Billy comes from the field in the 56th minute

**

So for you blokes who would rather look at stats than actually watch the game...

Billy was on for 8 minutes of action. During this 8 minutes...
- Sharks had the ball for 11 tackles, four of which were used by having outside backs run from dummy half
- From the remaining 7 tackles when they had the ball, Billy took one hit up and was involved in a passing movement which led to a half break
- Dragons had the ball for 26 tackles. Billy made 10 of them, missed none, and 5/5 times led the kick chase

If you didn't notice him or think he was poor it is because he wasn't out there long and the Sharks didn't have the footy much when he was. His stint was as good as you could ever expect from a bench forward, and I'm sure his teammates and coach appreciate his involvement in defence.
 

Sparkles

Jaws
Joined
May 21, 2008
Messages
12,007
Reaction score
2,736
I'm getting this all made into a coffee table book... Brilliant.

... Except for one item in the Tracey breakdown:
Tracey throws a shocker out in front of Chad
Should read...
Chad fails to be in the right position to take the pass from Tracey.

Otherwise, perfect ;)
 

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
29,949
Reaction score
5,844
Location
IN A BAR
Nice one Burgs.... so onto the starting 13 now or need to rest up for next weeks bench report?
 

Capital_Shark

Kitty Master
Joined
May 7, 2006
Messages
17,733
Reaction score
2,386
Looking forward to the write up when a benchie has to play 79mins
 
Joined
Sep 7, 2005
Messages
18,345
Reaction score
2,012
Location
The Ridge!
Great stuff mate.

There is only one phrase that puzzles me - I'm not sure what you mean when you say knees + elbows = quick ptb. I know what ptb means but not sure what you mean by knees and elbows.
 

Wiz

Jaws
Joined
Mar 23, 2016
Messages
5,906
Reaction score
1,514
Great stuff mate.

There is only one phrase that puzzles me - I'm not sure what you mean when you say knees + elbows = quick ptb. I know what ptb means but not sure what you mean by knees and elbows.

Lands on knees and elbows - leads to a fast play the ball.. which is ideal
 

Capital_Shark

Kitty Master
Joined
May 7, 2006
Messages
17,733
Reaction score
2,386
Great stuff mate.

There is only one phrase that puzzles me - I'm not sure what you mean when you say knees + elbows = quick ptb. I know what ptb means but not sure what you mean by knees and elbows.

Not laid out. If you're on knees & elbows you'll find your feet quicker than dominated flat on belly or back.
 

Blair

Bull Shark
Joined
Jul 5, 2010
Messages
1,906
Reaction score
127
I live for this kind of $#.t. Thanks Burgess.

Wondering how you explain this to the mrs, if you have one...

Mrs Burgess: What are you doing in there? You've been on your laptop for hours.
Burgess: I am going through the sharks game and writing up a minute-by-minute summary of all of the interchange players.
Mrs Burgess: WTF for?
Burgess: For a bunch of dudes on a sharks forum.
Mrs Burgess: Why?
Burgess: Cause... Shut up, that's why.
 
Top