3-2-1 Thread: Cronulla vs Souths, NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2010

Status
Not open for further replies.

SF

Mako Shark
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
9,862
Reaction score
1,368
Location
Monty Porter Stand
This is the 3-2-1 thread for the match:

Souths 30 - Cronulla 8
NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2010
Toyota Stadium, 7:30 pm, Monday March 29, 2010


To add your 3-2-1 and/or comments, please
fill out the form on the match review page.

  • Filling in the above form allows the 3-2-1 to be automatically calculated, and your comments added to this thread.
  • Please login before voting if you want to have your votes recorded under your username.
  • Ratings are open for a period of two weeks after the match.
  • Only one vote per IP address/username is allowed.
  • Please allocate at least your 3-2-1 points. Comments and additional ratings are optional for all players. However, you can't go back and add/edit ratings after you vote.
  • The results for this match are also available on the match review page once you have voted (or skipped voting).
  • The leaderboard for this season is available here.
 

SF

Mako Shark
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
9,862
Reaction score
1,368
Location
Monty Porter Stand
Sharks Forever's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2010)

3 Points - Luke Douglas: Flat, but a lot of work. Honestly I didn't have a clue who to give this to so he gets it by default for no dropped balls and lots of tackles. Still needs to develop more in attack.
2 Points - Blake Ferguson: A few mistakes and a bit lazy in defence, but made some good breaks in the second half.
1 Point - Adam Cuthbertson: Again a bad mistake on his first hitup, but pretty good from there on. Nice offloads.

- Albert Kelly: Horrible night under the bombs basically cost any chance of the game, but confident and dangerous in attack and other kick returns. Will come back strong.
- Nathan Stapleton: Looked fairly suited to the centres, and helped set up Covell - did not notice his defence though.
- Dean Collis: Injured early. Made the least mistakes on the field.
- Luke Covell: Good try early.
- Trent Barrett: Had a lot of ball, but always contained and with no room to move. Did his best as always.
- John Morris: Good as a dummy-half type runner. Passing pretty good. Back to hooker next week!
- Kade Snowden: Has been very quiet this year.
- Paul Aiton: Not as dynamic when starting.
- Grant Millington: Did not notice.
- Siosaia Vave: A couple of good runs.




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
29,404
Reaction score
5,519
Location
IN A BAR
bort's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2010)

3 Points - Blake Ferguson: Made a few errors with ball in hand but looked extremely dangerous, I maintain that (at least for now) his best position is on the wing. Notched up another try too. (7/10)
2 Points - Anthony Tupou: Looked very dangerous running around at centre and linking with Fergie and still managed 33 tackles. I honestly believe the Toops/Fergie combo may be worth points to us. (7/10)
1 Point - Nathan Stapleton: Isn't it nice having a centre that can pass? I thought Stapleton played very well and would definately like to see him play more in the centres, provided a fullback can be found. Does need to 'HTFU' a little though. (7/10)

- Albert Kelly: Made 4 of our sides 18 errors but was great with ball in hand. Showed great potential and if he had caught a couple of those bombs hed have got my three points and an 8/10 from me but alas he didn't, leading to 2 souths tries. Kelly cannot be allowed back into fullback. Definate half of the future and I think could go alright on the wing. (5/10)
- Dean Collis: Dean Who? Oh that injury prone guy that we signed from the Tigers? Everyone on here was so excited he was making his big debut and then (despite starting strong) off he limps. Sure this time it may just be a 'rolled ankle' but we can't afford to have players dragging themselves off the field at the start of games. (4/10)
- Luke Covell: 3 errors and a try. I guess compared to the rest of the side thats not so bad. Plus he can kick, oh, wait he can't kick anymore either it seems. He's no real use then, is he? (5/10)
- Trent Barrett: The inspirational leader of the Sharks. 8 runs for 48 meters and 5 tackles (1 miss) may yet explain our uninspired performance. You are ment to be our leader, try doing some of that. Kicked okay though... (4/10)
- John Morris: Probably the best game i've seen him play at half back and he didnt really do that much (and still managed 3 errors). Difference between him and porter? Minimal. (5/10)
- Kade Snowden: 10 runs 38 tackles is alright but I definately want more from Snowy, he has showed the potential in the past, maybe he needs to throw in a headbutt or a high tackle to get back into his zone. (6/10)
- Paul Aiton: Didn't really do himself any favours in regards to clinching the 9, I remember 1 really good run and solid defense, but Morris was managing that. (5/10)
- Luke Douglas: 13 runs 45 tackles typical workhorse game and managed to keep the errors out too. Much better meter gain and workload than his 100th although he did miss four tackles. (7/10)
- Grant Millington: 5 runs 37 tackles and he played almost the same minutes as Snowden, nothing really worth mentioning about Millo, as usual. (5/10)
- Paul Gallen: Easily topped our run chart but dropped a ball and got shamed by Champion and missed four tackles. (6/10)
- Adam Cuthbertson: 14 runs in 43 minutes makes him one of our hardest working offensive forwards. Managed 3 offloads but at the expense of 1 error, admittedly off his first touch so maybe he was just rusty. (6/10)
- Josh Cordoba: May like to consider making more than 7 runs but then his tackle count was decent. Needs to watch out for peoples heads, hitting his own and hitting his arm. All in all another less than noticable job. (5/10)
- Stuart Flanagan: In half an hour of footy he missed 2 (of 11) tackles and made an error. Looking at the performances of his competition I don't really see much reason he should be in first grade off this performance, but there was promised enough that I wouldn't be outraged should he gain more opportunity. (5/10)
- Siosaia Vave: Solid enough on debut, very limited game time and did very little with it, although we were well and truly on the backfoot by the time Vave hit the grass. Saw him get down nice and low to tackle someones legs at one point which is a good sign from a big fella. (5/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

Scarface

Hammerhead
Joined
Jan 10, 2010
Messages
380
Reaction score
0
Scarface's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2010)

3 Points - Paul Gallen: thought he played well as he always does, shame bout the couple dropped balls and the few missed tackles. (7/10)
2 Points - Luke Douglas: another good game from douglas. in my opinion anyway. (7/10)
1 Point - Trent Barrett: thought barrett played very well tonight, alot better than the last couple of games, seemed to play well with morris. hopes he plays a lot better with smith though lol. (7/10)

- Albert Kelly: wasnt too great a game for him. shouldnt be allowed to play fullback again, cant catch the high balls. though did like some of his returns. (5/10)
- Blake Ferguson: thought he looked more comfortable on the wing then in the centres, great to see him score again would love to seen that more. couple of handling errors but thought he played well. (7/10)
- Nathan Stapleton: did really well as a centre i thought but i prefer him back a fullback, he seems quite confident back there under the high ball, unless they try gardner out at fullback. (7/10)
- Dean Collis: shame to see him go so early in the game, thought he was looking quite dangerous with the ball, hope he fine for the next game. (4/10)
- Luke Covell: played well this game despite the few handling errors. was disappointed with the 2 missed conversions. (5/10)
- John Morris: though he was decent tonight, brought in a running game as the halfback which the team has been needing. but will be back at 9 next week. (7/10)
- Paul Aiton: thought he played decent a couple poor decisions, seems to play a lot better off the bench. (6/10)
- Josh Cordoba: thought he played well seems to be a pretty consistent player. (5/10)
- Siosaia Vave: had a few decent runs would have liked to have seen him come on earlier though. (5/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

ROB SHARK

Great White
Joined
Apr 8, 2009
Messages
2,633
Reaction score
6
Location
Shire
ROB SHARK's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2010)

3 Points - Luke Douglas: lots of work in defence
2 Points - Blake Ferguson: scored a try and saved one.
1 Point - Luke Covell: scored a try

- Albert Kelly: bad gam under the high ball but is a star of the future (4/10)
- Nathan Stapleton: looks better in th centres and passes to cov (6/10)
- Dean Collis: wasnt on the field for long (1/10)
- Trent Barrett: rubbish, providing no attack what-soever. Captain should be leading he isnt. (3/10)
- John Morris: not a 7, much better at 9 (3/10)
- Kade Snowden: same as dougy (5/10)
- Paul Aiton: tried hard to create something (5/10)
- Grant Millington: needs to stop throwing crap offloads (3/10)
- Anthony Tupou: run the ball more ffs, dont turn into a nathan hindmarsh (4/10)
- Paul Gallen: was well contained by beau champion (5/10)
- Adam Cuthbertson: again wih the wrong time to offload (4/10)
- Josh Cordoba: defensively was good made lots of tackles (5/10)
- Stuart Flanagan: running out of dummyhalf was good (4/10)
- Siosaia Vave: ok first game (4/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

Soon I Hope

Bronze Whaler
Joined
Jul 7, 2009
Messages
153
Reaction score
40
Soon I Hope's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2010)

3 Points - Paul Gallen
2 Points - Adam Cuthbertson
1 Point - Nathan Stapleton

- Albert Kelly: can not be blamed for the result, yes he dropped the ball, the best fullbacks would have had trouble with those, but fact remains DEFENCE was soft on our line after that, this is where tries where scored.




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

DruNkDazZ

Oceanic Whitetip Shark
Joined
Jun 2, 2008
Messages
998
Reaction score
7
Location
Caringbah
DruNkDazZ's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2010)

3 Points - Luke Douglas: GREAT effort. 45 tackles, 120 metres gained. (9/10)
2 Points - Paul Gallen: Good go forward from Gallen, as always (7/10)
1 Point - Adam Cuthbertson: Few little mistakes needs to get out of his game. But good game. (7/10)

- Albert Kelly: Tought night at the back. Needs more time, Will deliver (6/10)
- Blake Ferguson: Hard for someone like Ferg to shine in this sort of game. Wet track & not enough ball once again. (6/10)
- Nathan Stapleton: Needs to imporve on his defence (6/10)
- Dean Collis: Came to the club injured, continues to be injured. (4/10)
- Luke Covell: Went ok. . (6/10)
- Trent Barrett: Didn't impact yet again. (6/10)
- John Morris: Went ok, but, wasn't much there to do with the ball, Not enough time in our attacking zone. (6/10)
- Kade Snowden: Not as effective as last year so far (6/10)
- Paul Aiton: Alot of sideway movement, need to go straight my friend (6/10)
- Grant Millington: Not good performance (6/10)
- Anthony Tupou: Was pushed to the centres, not as dangerous there (6/10)
- Josh Cordoba: Good tackle count, put in the effort (7/10)
- Stuart Flanagan: Yeah, nah, was a fill in i beleive, will be back to NSW cup. (6/10)
- Siosaia Vave: Went good for debut. Needs more time in first grade. (6/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

Mark^Bastard

Great White
Joined
May 6, 2009
Messages
17,725
Reaction score
167
Location
Brisbane
Mark^Bastard's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2010)

3 Points - Paul Aiton: Great player. We certainly have no problems at hooker. (7/10)
2 Points - Adam Cuthbertson: Cuthbertson is big and looks dangerous in attack. I like it. (7/10)
1 Point - Paul Gallen: I feel sorry for you Gallen. You deserve better. (7/10)

- Albert Kelly: I'm giving him 1/10 for that performance but I don't blame him. It's not his fault he was chucked into first grade on a rainy night completely out of position. (1/10)
- Blake Ferguson: He tried hard and made a few breaks. (5/10)
- Nathan Stapleton: Looked quite promising in the centres but still by far our best fullback so would like to see him return there. (6/10)
- Dean Collis: Thanks for nothing, I would like to see him just dropped and forgotten about. Why bother training with him, he's clearly worse than Kearney and Ross and we're all deluded. (1/10)
- Luke Covell: Solid game. (5/10)
- Trent Barrett: Not showing leadership. Not grabbing the game by the balls. (2/10)
- John Morris: Was one of our best players and was competent at half back. I probably deserve to eat my own hat. (6/10)
- Kade Snowden: Saw him standing around lazy when a try was run in. This isn't under 12's and you're not the fat kit anymore. (5/10)
- Luke Douglas: Had a dig (6/10)
- Grant Millington: ??? Just not a first grader I'm sorry. Gave you some good raps at the start of the year but meh. (3/10)
- Anthony Tupou: Looked really good at centre but we missed him in the forwards. Great running game in broken play. A better coach would get more out of him. (6/10)
- Josh Cordoba: Most under rated player in the team. Solid. (6/10)
- Stuart Flanagan: Okay as a bench hooker. Didn't do a lot. Haven't seen enough. (5/10)
- Siosaia Vave: Good debut. I really liked how mobile he looked for a big fella. (6/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

Ibanez

Great White
Joined
Sep 26, 2008
Messages
4,240
Reaction score
40
Location
All up in your pixels
Ibanez's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2010)

3 Points - Nathan Stapleton: Looked much more comfortable out in the centres. Good passing game, relatively solid defence. (6/10)
2 Points - Paul Aiton: Once again one of our better players - always looks deadly on the run. (6/10)
1 Point - John Morris: In all honesty, I thought he didn't play too bad at halfback. At least he attempted to get the ball out to the backs. (6/10)

- Albert Kelly: He's not a fullback. Simple. Apart from that, we saw a glimpse of what he's like when he runs the ball. For a boy his size, he almost managed to break the line numerous times from kick returns. I've lost no faith in Kelly. (4/10)
- Blake Ferguson: Meh. (4/10)
- Dean Collis: Brett Kearny? (1/10)
- Luke Covell: Waste of a position. (2/10)
- Trent Barrett: One of his better games, getting a bit more involved - however he still looked once Bunnies started packing points on us. (4/10)
- Kade Snowden: Meh. (4/10)
- Luke Douglas: Meh. (4/10)
- Grant Millington: Disappointing once again. (2/10)
- Anthony Tupou: Who? (2/10)
- Paul Gallen: Was quiet. (4/10)
- Adam Cuthbertson: Still plenty of dumb errors in his game, but hit it up hard. (4/10)
- Josh Cordoba: Meh. (2/10)
- Stuart Flanagan: Disappointing. (2/10)
- Siosaia Vave: Not bad. (4/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

Doctors_Advocate

Bronze Whaler
Joined
Jun 29, 2007
Messages
72
Reaction score
0
Location
...:???:...
Doctors_Advocate's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2010)

3 Points - Luke Douglas: the champ (9/10)
2 Points - Nathan Stapleton: OUR BEST FULLBACK (8/10)
1 Point - Stuart Flanagan: will give Aiton and Morris a run for hooker (7/10)

- Albert Kelly: useless under the high ball but looks the goods when he has the ball in his hands! (4/10)
- Blake Ferguson: looks more like Inglis' cousin then Kelly lol (6/10)
- Dean Collis: waste of money!! (1/10)
- Luke Covell: cant convert anymore (4/10)
- Trent Barrett: needs to lift (5/10)
- John Morris: should stick to hooker (6/10)
- Kade Snowden: the man (8/10)
- Paul Aiton: Kingston is goin better (6/10)
- Grant Millington: good stuff (7/10)
- Anthony Tupou: needs to get more involved (3/10)
- Paul Gallen: bring back the biff (8/10)
- Adam Cuthbertson: what happen to the ball playin forward?? (6/10)
- Josh Cordoba: will struggle to keep his position in first grade (5/10)
- Siosaia Vave: big boy! (5/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
U

Unregistered

Guest
Unregistered user's ratings for Cronulla vs Souths (NRL Premiership, Round 3, 2010)

3 Points - Paul Aiton: gr8 player - hard for him when he has nothing 2 work with! (8/10)
2 Points - Luke Covell (6/10)
1 Point - Paul Gallen (7/10)

- Blake Ferguson (5/10)
- Trent Barrett (4/10)
- John Morris (4/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top