3-2-1 Thread: Cronulla vs Melbourne, NRL Premiership, Round 24, 2010

Status
Not open for further replies.

SF

Mako Shark
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
9,862
Reaction score
1,368
Location
Monty Porter Stand
This is the 3-2-1 thread for the match:

Melbourne 24 - Cronulla 4
NRL Premiership, Round 24, 2010
, 7:30 pm, Saturday August 21, 2010


To add your 3-2-1 and/or comments, please
fill out the form on the match review page.

  • Filling in the above form allows the 3-2-1 to be automatically calculated, and your comments added to this thread.
  • Please login before voting if you want to have your votes recorded under your username.
  • Ratings are open for a period of two weeks after the match.
  • Only one vote per IP address/username is allowed.
  • Please allocate at least your 3-2-1 points. Comments and additional ratings are optional for all players. However, you can't go back and add/edit ratings after you vote.
  • The results for this match are also available on the match review page once you have voted (or skipped voting).
  • The leaderboard for this season is available here.
 

SF

Mako Shark
Joined
Dec 16, 2005
Messages
9,862
Reaction score
1,368
Location
Monty Porter Stand
Sharks Forever's ratings for Cronulla vs Melbourne (NRL Premiership, Round 24, 2010)

3 Points - Luke Covell: Saved a number of tries in the first half, and scored our only try from nothing. (8/10)
2 Points - Nathan Gardner: Billy Slater took him on personally, and he held his own. Never gave up.
1 Point - Grant Millington: Looked dangerous early on, and did plenty of work





Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

Shark68

Bull Shark
Joined
Mar 27, 2008
Messages
2,052
Reaction score
18
Shark68's ratings for Cronulla vs Melbourne (NRL Premiership, Round 24, 2010)

3 Points - Luke Covell (7/10)
2 Points - Paul Gallen (7/10)
1 Point - Nathan Gardner (7/10)

- Blake Ferguson (6/10)
- Dean Collis (6/10)
- Ricky Leutele (6/10)
- Trent Barrett (6/10)
- Tim Smith (6/10)
- Kade Snowden (7/10)
- John Morris (6/10)
- Luke Douglas (7/10)
- Taulima Tautai (6/10)
- Anthony Tupou (7/10)
- Adam Cuthbertson (5/10)
- Broderick Wright (5/10)
- Paul Aiton (6/10)
- Grant Millington (7/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

Ramzyv1

Great White
Joined
May 21, 2009
Messages
2,677
Reaction score
18
Ramzyv1's ratings for Cronulla vs Melbourne (NRL Premiership, Round 24, 2010)

3 Points - Nathan Gardner: Was outstanding once again when being heavily targeted. (9/10)
2 Points - Luke Covell: Was very good, saved a number of tries and can really hold his head high. Finishing his career very well. Does he really have to go? (8/10)
1 Point - Paul Gallen: Wasn't his best game when comparing to other performances but still he was a monster as usual and set up our only try. (8/10)

- Blake Ferguson: Was ok. Did some good things but I expect more from him. His heart may well not be in it. (6/10)
- Dean Collis: Didn't do alot but was ok. (6/10)
- Ricky Leutele: Did nothing in attack and was our weak point in defence. The score flattered the Storm and this guy was a reason for it. I hope to see him back but he is not up to it defensively yet. (4/10)
- Trent Barrett: Disappointing game. I hope I am wrong but he looks like he has already checked out. Hope the injury is minor as it would be a sad way to finish. (5/10)
- Tim Smith: Probably his best game for us. His kicking was better than Barrett's and he just looked alot more composed. Having said that his defence was an issue. The miss with him and leutele on Manu led to the first try and isn't good enough. (7/10)
- Kade Snowden: Was strong but I have seen him better. (7/10)
- John Morris: Played ok. (6/10)
- Luke Douglas: Had a strong game. (7/10)
- Taulima Tautai: Not good at all. Sadly he has played much worse when at centre but I really think we can find someone better than him. He is better in the backrow than in centres but there are players better than him at both so why is he there? (5/10)
- Anthony Tupou: Did what he could. I thought he had a good game but discipline was an issue. (6/10)
- Adam Cuthbertson: Was really hoping he would do well tonight but he was lazy, slow, made ineffective tackles and blew a good attacking option. He is ****. (3/10)
- Broderick Wright: Didn't notice him until he missed a tackle at the end of the game for the last try (after leutele screwed up first). He did well to get there but once there he didnt get it done. Average player imo. (5/10)
- Paul Aiton: Needed to do more when he was on but he is a classy player who always creates something. (6/10)
- Grant Millington: Was better tonight and if we don't get Fa'alogo (or even if we do) I would love to have him around if possible. Should have found an offload to Gardner when he made that break tho. (7/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

Ibanez

Great White
Joined
Sep 26, 2008
Messages
4,240
Reaction score
40
Location
All up in your pixels
Ibanez's ratings for Cronulla vs Melbourne (NRL Premiership, Round 24, 2010)

3 Points - Nathan Gardner: Our only player creating worry for the cheats.
2 Points - Luke Douglas: One of his better games, was hitting it up hard.
1 Point - Grant Millington: Played well, looked good with the ball.

- Blake Ferguson: Played well. Still hate him.
- Dean Collis: Was solid, needs to touch the ball more.
- Luke Covell: Great defensive effort.
- Trent Barrett: Less than impressed with his form the past couple weeks.
- Tim Smith: Run at the line son, jesus christ.
- Adam Cuthbertson: Lazy.
- Paul Aiton: Needs more minutes than Morris, for ****s sake.




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 

A.Snowden

Jaws
Joined
Jun 17, 2009
Messages
15,838
Reaction score
156
Location
Mac Fields Represent
A.Snowden's ratings for Cronulla vs Melbourne (NRL Premiership, Round 24, 2010)

3 Points - Grant Millington (9/10)
2 Points - Nathan Gardner (8/10)
1 Point - Luke Covell (8/10)

- Blake Ferguson (7/10)
- Dean Collis (7/10)
- Ricky Leutele (6/10)
- Trent Barrett (6/10)
- Tim Smith (6/10)
- Kade Snowden (8/10)
- John Morris (6/10)
- Luke Douglas (8/10)
- Taulima Tautai (7/10)
- Anthony Tupou (7/10)
- Paul Gallen (8/10)
- Adam Cuthbertson (6/10)
- Broderick Wright (5/10)
- Paul Aiton (7/10)




Click here to select your 3-2-1!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top