Official 2024 NRL General Discussion (no off-field controversies/rumours)

MrDravid

Great White
Joined
Apr 11, 2022
Messages
3,487
Reaction score
2,317
I honestly dont see a world where they lose tonight, they're going to be far too good defensively for a Roosters attack missing Walker.

I actually see them winning 13+ easily

Who do I want to win, well I hate both teams equally - I want to see the Panthers era end but also dont want the Roosters winning
I agree... Even with Penrith not playing well, I think they'll do it easy.
 

Thresher

Jaws
Joined
Jul 5, 2011
Messages
25,647
Reaction score
4,571
Location
Melbourne
I just saw a tweet by someone with the handle JaC which said, "It takes a lot of broken eggs to make an omelette"

Not sure what to make of this.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: egg

apezza

Jaws
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
7,244
Reaction score
5,490
You have to wonder how JACs test came back so quickly during the week of the finals.

Tell me someone, somewhere isn't pulling some local government agenda (ie anti Bulldogs or anti NRL)

Oh wait, there's local government elections tomorrow...
 

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
33,453
Reaction score
9,122
Location
IN A BAR
You have to wonder how JACs test came back so quickly during the week of the finals.

Tell me someone, somewhere isn't pulling some local government agenda (ie anti Bulldogs or anti NRL)

Oh wait, there's local government elections tomorrow...
The tests don’t need to ferment - they can rush it through if they choose to
May have done so because of their need to break protocol for an urgent response

The supposed photo of alleged him with a mystery white unknown substance in it won’t help his case (with the Integrity, won’t affect his legal situation)
 

apezza

Jaws
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
7,244
Reaction score
5,490
The tests don’t need to ferment - they can rush it through if they choose to
May have done so because of their need to break protocol for an urgent response

The supposed photo of alleged him with a mystery white unknown substance in it won’t help his case (with the Integrity, won’t affect his legal situation)
Wow. Haven't heard about the photo.
 

Born&bred

Jaws
Joined
Apr 1, 2010
Messages
13,424
Reaction score
1,483
Location
The Bar

Bulldogs star returns second positive drug test​

An oral sample taken from Bulldogs winger Josh Addo-Carr has returned a positive reading, according to police.
Cydonee Mardon, David Riccio and Phil Rothfield

4 min read
September 13, 2024 - 5:28PM

An oral sample taken from Bulldogs winger Josh Addo-Carr has returned a positive reading, according to police.
Addo-Carr was pulled over on Friday night while driving in the Sydney suburb of Wentworth Point and allegedly returned a positive test.
He was then tested a second time, with the sample sent away for further analysis.
NSW Police sources said the test came back positive on Friday.
It can be revealed that Addo-Carr, after a meeting with his lawyer Elias Tabchouri, has decided to pay the fine of $682 and will automatically be disqualfied from driving for three months. It is understood he is making no admission of guilt, but wants to avoide lengthy court proceedings.
Sources close to Addo-Carr say that the champion winger is still insisting he has not taken cocaine, even in light of the new test result.

LAWYER, CLUB ISSUE STATEMENTS​

Late on Friday afternoon Tabchouri made a statement on Abdo-Carr’s behalf.
“Josh was issued with an infringement notice from NSW Police in relation to positive test results.
“This matter has had a dramatic impact on Josh and his family.
“It has also been a distraction from a significant game for his beloved Bulldogs.
“Despite the fact that Josh maintains that he has never knowingly ingested any illegal drugs he has decided to pay the infringement and bring this matter to an end legally.
“He appreciates all the support of the club, particularly the General Manager Phil Gould, the coach Cameron Ciraldo.
“Finally he wishes to thank his family, management and team mates and the fans for all their support.”
The statement followed an earlier one from the the Bulldogs confirming that they had been informed of the result.
“The Canterbury-Bankstown Bulldogs have been advised that NRL Squad member Josh Addo-Carr has returned a positive result on the second sample taken on Friday night (September 6) at a NSW Police random roadside illicit drug test.
“Josh has left training to be with his manager, Mario Tartak. The Club is offering Josh appropriate support during this difficult period.
“The Bulldogs are committed to following the appropriate protocols with regards to the player’s contract and CBA and will work with the NRL Integrity unit, the player and his management team accordingly throughout further investigations.
“While we treat this issue with utmost seriousness, Josh’s welfare is our highest priority at this time. We will not be making any further comment until more information is available to the club. We request that the privacy of Josh and his family be respected during this challenging time.
“In the meantime, our focus remains steadfast on preparation for Sunday’s match.”

An initial test of Addo-Carr on Friday, September 6 showed indications of cocaine, but he was not charged as police awaited the results of the oral sample.
Addo-Carr denied to club officials that he took any illegal drugs, but was stood down for the club’s return to the finals against Manly on Sunday in a bid to ease the pressure on the club and his teammates.
In a statement released on Friday afternoon NSW Police confirmed they had served an infringement notice for the offence of drive motor vehicle with illicit drug present in oral fluid – first offence - on the 29-year-old man’s legal representative.
“About 10.45pm on Friday 6 September 2024, officers attached to Auburn Police Area Command were patrolling Baywater Drive, Wentworth Point, when they stopped a Toyota hatchback for random testing.

“The driver - a 29-year-old man - was subjected to a roadside breath test which returned a negative result.
“The driver underwent a preliminary drug wipe, which allegedly returned a positive indication.
“An oral fluid sample was obtained and sent for further analysis.
“On Friday 13 September 2024, Auburn Police received notification that the sample had been analysed and returned a positive reading to cocaine.”
NSW Police had released a statement on Tuesday afternoon confirming reports that Addo-Carr was not subject to a second swab last Friday night because officers were called away to attend an urgent matter.
“About 10.45pm on Friday, officers attached to Auburn Police Area Command were patrolling Baywater Drive, Wentworth Point, when they stopped a Toyota hatchback for random testing,” the police statement said.
“The driver - a 29-year-old man - was subject to a roadside breath test which returned a negative result. The driver underwent a preliminary drug wipe, which allegedly returned a positive indication.

“An oral fluid sample was obtained and sent for further analysis. At this time, an urgent call for assistance was received in relation to a reported attempted home invasion on Church Street, Lidcombe, about 10.54pm.
“A secondary drug wipe was not conducted as officers were required to respond to the urgent call. Auburn Police Area Command has reviewed the incident and is satisfied with the actions of the officers involved.
“The investigation is ongoing, as police await the results of the forensic analysis. No charges have been laid at this time.”
Calls to Bulldogs CEO Aaron Warburton and GM of football Phil Gould went unanswered on Friday afternoon with the club forced to deal with the bombshell news.

In detailing his version of events of last Friday night to Canterbury officials, Addo-Carr had been vehement in denying any cocaine use.
Following high-powered meetings with the club’s hierarchy, the Test and NSW State of Origin winger made the decision to stand down from the Dogs huge elimination final clash against the Sea Eagles on Sunday in a decision designed to take the spotlight away from his teammates.
However, if police charges are laid against Addo-Carr, the major development will prompt the Bulldogs into making a career-defining call on the popular winger, which would include the potential of tearing-up his $500,000 per-season contract.
The Bulldogs will want answers on how it could be possible that Addo-Carr has returned a positive reading after repeatedly denying any illicit drug-use.
If charges are laid and Addo-Carr opts to plead not-guilty, any decision on whether he plays again this season will be at the discretion of the Bulldogs.
He would not fall under the NRL’s strict no-fault stand-down policy.
 

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
33,453
Reaction score
9,122
Location
IN A BAR
I think it's a bit rough blaming the ref for a 50/50 call when you let in 24 points to start the game....

Then again it is Klein.

‘You can’t get that wrong’: Robbo blasts veteran ref after brutal call denies Roosters comeback https://www.foxsports.com.au/nrl/nr...s/news-story/f64b347b8a7690c7d97b7b261f174965
Thought it was a bit harsh a call, especially as ref had just ignored a trip not long before (if I recall correctly)

Can’t blame the ref for being down like they were but doesn’t mean they don’t deserve a fair chance to come back.

Unfortunately officials can and never will be perfect. All you can do is hope they are relatively consistent, you come out on the luckier side on the day, and you play well enough a small mistake here or there doesn’t hurt you (even better if you can outplay an egregious mistake or two, as those are likely…)
 

Pishposh46

Bull Shark
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
2,456
Reaction score
1,334
Thought it was a bit harsh a call, especially as ref had just ignored a trip not long before (if I recall correctly)

Can’t blame the ref for being down like they were but doesn’t mean they don’t deserve a fair chance to come back.

Unfortunately officials can and never will be perfect. All you can do is hope they are relatively consistent, you come out on the luckier side on the day, and you play well enough a small mistake here or there doesn’t hurt you (even better if you can outplay an egregious mistake or two, as those are likely…)
True, but don't worry, Klein will get another gig next week and Adam Gee apparently is out of form.
 

Pishposh46

Bull Shark
Joined
Sep 16, 2018
Messages
2,456
Reaction score
1,334
Just heard on radio that Dino Mezzatesta has asked if the Sharks can hold next week's game at Shark Park rather than Allianz as it will clash with the Swans game plus he reckons they wouldn't get more than 15000 at Allianz anyway. Don't like his chances especially if the Knights win, as they do travel.
 

egg

Jaws
Joined
Apr 11, 2010
Messages
13,276
Reaction score
1,471
HOPEFULLY THE LAST WE HEAR FROM MR X

JOURNO SETTLES DISMISSAL CASE​

Former Fox Sports journalist and veteran sports writer Mr X has settled his wrongful dismissal lawsuit against News Limited out of court.

The two parties agreed on a settlement recently after Mr X launched action challenging his termination with the Fair Work Commission.

The former NRL 360 host and Daily Telegraph columnist was stood down after video footage of him fighting with another man outside well known Sydney eatery Totti's restaurant in Rozelle went viral in April.

He was dismissed by the company three months later.

All details of the agreement between Mr X and News Limited remain confidential.
 
Top