Official Braydon Trindall

bort

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
29,908
Reaction score
5,822
Location
IN A BAR
sharks2010 said:
**** all, iro and stonestreet haven't played a game, moylan and Brailey haven't been dropped. Wilton still playing despite not committing and Dale is past it

And what the heck more does newtowns waterboy have to do to get a promotion ffs
Click to expand...
Iro not even getting a run with Jets how’s he gunna play NRL
 
BlackWhiteBlue

BlackWhiteBlue

Jaws
Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
28,394
Reaction score
737
Location
NSW
Sevshark said:
Tricky's stats yesterday in NSW cup:
1 try 4 try assists 1 offload
21 runs 104m
3 tackle breaks 1 Line break 3 LB assists
11 kicks 265m
14 tackles 5 misses 1 error
Click to expand...
I reckon Moylan would post similar of not better numbers if he ran out for newtown.

Less than 75% tackling efficiency is a huge concern there too
 
BlackWhiteBlue

BlackWhiteBlue

Jaws
Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
28,394
Reaction score
737
Location
NSW
team currently has the best attack in the comp, but people think we need changes in the player making role?

Our bigs need to do their jobs a bit better (regardless of injury they all have a job to do when called up).

I dont mind Trindall, in fact i quite like him, but i highly doubt hes the reason we’d start putting 50 on teams every week.

The games we’ve lost werent due to attack
 
bort

bort

Jaws
Joined
Jun 4, 2007
Messages
29,908
Reaction score
5,822
Location
IN A BAR
BlackWhiteBlue said:
team currently has the best attack in the comp, but people think we need changes in the player making role?

Our bigs need to do their jobs a bit better (regardless of injury they all have a job to do when called up).

I dont mind Trindall, in fact i quite like him, but i highly doubt hes the reason we’d start putting 50 on teams every week.

The games we’ve lost werent due to attack
Click to expand...
I don't think our bigs have been too bad, all things considered.

For me there are two major issues
  • sloppy play
  • goal line defence
Sloppy play - we are a heavily attack oriented team and our spine skillset leans into that, even our half who I do think can control a game, has an eyes up mentality and is willing to take risks. As a result we have the 3rd worst (by average) error rate - 11.3 per game. Generally we can hold them off and recover, but not always (Warriors game for example, slow scoring in first 40 vs Knights). Moylan has made 6 errors in 11 games. He is not the issue here. Trindall has 3 in 3 games, small sample but not screaming out as an improvement. A symptom of this attacking play is also being equal first on the ladder, with one of the best attacks.

Goal Line Defence - maybe a little worse on left but bad across the park. Moylan contributes to it being bad but so do the men either side of him and plenty of others in the team have been burned. It is very hypothetical that Trindall improves this.

With Hynes in NSW team Trindall gets more chances to audition for a regular spot, if he is so infinitely better surely he will secure it?
 
BlackWhiteBlue

BlackWhiteBlue

Jaws
Joined
May 17, 2010
Messages
28,394
Reaction score
737
Location
NSW
bort said:
I don't think our bigs have been too bad, all things considered.

For me there are two major issues
  • sloppy play
  • goal line defence
Sloppy play - we are a heavily attack oriented team and our spine skillset leans into that, even our half who I do think can control a game, has an eyes up mentality and is willing to take risks. As a result we have the 3rd worst (by average) error rate - 11.3 per game. Generally we can hold them off and recover, but not always (Warriors game for example, slow scoring in first 40 vs Knights). Moylan has made 6 errors in 11 games. He is not the issue here. Trindall has 3 in 3 games, small sample but not screaming out as an improvement. A symptom of this attacking play is also being equal first on the ladder, with one of the best attacks.

Goal Line Defence - maybe a little worse on left but bad across the park. Moylan contributes to it being bad but so do the men either side of him and plenty of others in the team have been burned. It is very hypothetical that Trindall improves this.

With Hynes in NSW team Trindall gets more chances to audition for a regular spot, if he is so infinitely better surely he will secure it?
Click to expand...
With Hynes in NSW team playing off the bench Trindall will get 2 games, against other depleted teams (if they have any out). Im not gauging anything from that.

Trindall/Hynes will happen at some stage, but i dont think that change is really required. I also dont think it improves the team much at all
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top